Pentanchids (Elasmobranchii) are among the most species-rich groups of chondrichthyans. In the North Atlantic Ocean, the Icelandic catshark [Apristurus laurussonii (Saemundsson)], white ghost catshark (Apristurus aphyodes Nakaya & Stehmann), and mouse catshark [Galeus murinus (Collett)] are commonly found in deepwater habitats. However, information on their parasite communities remains scarce. This study provides the first comprehensive characterization of the metazoan parasite communities of the 3 pentanchid species. In total, 56 specimens were collected in Icelandic waters at depths of 466–1322 m between 2023 and 2024 and examined using standardized parasitological protocols, including morphological and molecular methods. Infection patterns were assessed in relation to size, maturity, body condition and capture area of hosts. Parasite intensities in all sharks ranged from 2 to 227 individuals, comprising 15 different taxa and resulting in 27 new parasite–host records, some of which likely representing new species. Eight out of 9 commonly found parasites did not display a high degree of host-specificity, indicating similar feeding habits, niche preferences, and trophic position of these sympatric species. Nonetheless, multivariate analyses revealed significant differences in the structure and composition of their parasite assemblages, with some parasites representing indicator species and occurring more abundantly and frequently in a certain deepwater catshark species. In addition, significant small-scale geographic differences were detected. At a broader geographical scale, North Atlantic pentanchids showed higher parasite richness and diversity, and lower dominance compared to standardized data from Mediterranean counterparts. Ecological factors underlying these patterns on host–parasite dynamics in (deepwater) cat sharks are discussed.