Let T r be the first time at which a random walk S n escapes from the strip [-r,r], and let |S T r |-r be the overshoot of the boundary of the strip. We investigate the order of magnitude of the overshoot, as r → ∞, by providing necessary and sufficient conditions for the ‘stability’ of |S T r |, by which we mean that |S T r |/r converges to 1, either in probability (weakly) or almost surely (strongly), as r → ∞. These also turn out to be equivalent to requiring only the boundedness of |S T r |/r, rather than its convergence to 1, either in the weak or strong sense, as r → ∞. The almost sure characterisation turns out to be extremely simple to state and to apply: we have |S T r |/r → 1 a.s. if and only if EX 2 < ∞ and EX = 0 or 0 < |EX| ≤ E|X| < ∞. Proving this requires establishing the equivalence of the stability of S T r with certain dominance properties of the maximum partial sum S n * = max{|S j |: 1 ≤ j ≤ n} over its maximal increment.