Skip to main content

Parochial prosocial religions: Historical and contemporary evidence for a cultural evolutionary process

  • Ara Norenzayan (a1), Azim F. Shariff (a2), Will M. Gervais (a3), Aiyana K. Willard (a4), Rita A. McNamara (a1), Edward Slingerland (a5) and Joseph Henrich (a6) (a7)...

In our response to the 27 commentaries, we refine the theoretical claims, clarify several misconceptions of our framework, and explore substantial disagreements. In doing so, we (1) show that our framework accommodates multiple historical scenarios; (2) debate the historical evidence, particularly about “pre-Axial” religions; (3) offer important details about cultural evolutionary theory; (4) clarify the term prosociality; and (4) discuss proximal mechanisms. We review many interesting extensions, amplifications, and qualifications of our approach made by the commentators.

Hide All
Assmann J. (2003) The mind of Egypt: History and meaning in the time of the pharaohs. Harvard University Press.
Atran S. (2011) War, martyrdom, and terror: Evolutionary underpinnings of the moral imperative to extreme group violence. In: Applied evolutionary psychology, ed. Roberts S. C., pp. 222–38. Oxford University Press.
Atran S. & Henrich J. (2010) The evolution of religion: How cognitive by-products, adaptive learning heuristics, ritual displays, and group competition generate deep commitments to prosocial religions. Biological Theory: Integrating Development, Evolution, and Cognition 5:1830.
Atran S. & Norenzayan A. (2004) Religion's evolutionary landscape: Counterintuition, commitment, compassion, communion. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27:713–70.
Banerjee K. & Bloom P. (2014) Why did this happen to me? Religious believers' and non-believers' teleological reasoning about life events. Cognition 133:277303. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2014.06.017.
Banerjee K. & Bloom P. (2015) “Everything happens for a reason:” Children's beliefs about purpose in life events. Child Development 86:503–18.
Barrett J. L. (2004) Why would anyone believe in God? AltaMira Press.
Baumard N. & Chevallier C. (2012) What goes around comes around: The evolutionary roots of the belief in immanent justice. Journal of Cognition and Culture 12(1):6780.
Baumard N., Hyafil A., Morris I. & Boyer P. (2015) Increased affluence explains the emergence of ascetic wisdoms and moralizing religions. Current Biology 25(1):1015. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2014.10.063.
Bell A. V., Richerson P. & McElreath R. (2009) Culture rather than genes provides greater scope for the evolution of large-scale human prosociality. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 106:17671–74.
Bentzen J. S. (2013) Origins of religiousness: The role of natural disasters. Discussion Paper No. 13-02. Department of Economics, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark. Available at:
Blackmore S. J. (1999) The meme machine. Oxford University Press.
Bowles S. (2008) Conflict: Altruism's midwife. Science 456:326–27.
Boyd R. & Richerson P. J. (1985) Culture and the evolutionary process. University of Chicago Press.
Boyd R. & Richerson P. J. (1990b) Group selection among alternative evolutionarily stable strategies. Journal of Theoretical Biology 145:331–42.
Boyd R. & Richerson P. J. (2002) Group beneficial norms can spread rapidly in a structured population. Journal of Theoretical Biology 215:287–96.
Boyd R. & Richerson P. J. (2009) Voting with your feet: Payoff biased migration and the evolution of group beneficial behavior. Journal of Theoretical Biology 257:331–39.
Boyer P. (1994) The naturalness of religious ideas: A cognitive theory of religion. University of California Press.
Cavalli-Sforza L. L. & Feldman M. (1981) Cultural transmission and evolution. Princeton University Press.
Cavalli-Sforza L. L. & Feldman M. W. (1973a) Cultural versus biological inheritance – phenotypic transmission from parents to children – a theory of the effect of parental phenotypes on children's phenotypes. American Journal of Human Genetics 25(6):618–37.
Cavalli-Sforza L. L. & Feldman M. W. (1973b) Models for cultural inheritance .1. Group mean and within group variation. Theoretical Population Biology 4(1):4255.
Chudek M., Brosseau P., Birch S. & Henrich J. (2013) Culture-gene coevolutionary theory and children's selective social learning. In: The development of social cognition, ed. Banaji M. & Gelman S., pp. 181–85. Oxford.
Chudek M., Heller S., Birch S. & Henrich J. (2012) Prestige-biased cultural learning: Bystander's differential attention to potential models influences children's learning. Evolution and Human Behavior 33(1):4656.
Claidiere N. & Sperber D. (2007) The role of attraction in cultural evolution. Journal of Cognition and Culture 7:89111.
Clingingsmith D., Khwaja A. I. & Kremer M. (2009) Estimating the impact of The Hajj: Religion and tolerance in Islam's global gathering. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 124(3):1133–70.
Corriveau K. H., Chen E. E. & Harris P. L. (2015) Judgments about fact and fiction by children from religious and nonreligious backgrounds. Cognitive Science 39(2):353–82.
Corriveau K. H., Fusaro M. & Harris P. L. (2009) Going with the flow: Preschoolers prefer nondissenters as informants. Psychological Science 20(3):372–77.
Dawkins R. (1976) The selfish gene. Oxford University Press (new edition with additional material, 1989).
Dawkins R. (2006) The god delusion. Mariner Books.
Diamond J. (1997a) Guns, germs, and steel: The fates of human societies. Norton.
Fehr E. & Fischbacher U. (2004b) Third-party punishment and social norms. Evolution and Human Behavior 25:6387.
Fletcher J. A. & Doebeli M. (2009) A simple and general explanation for the evolution of altruism. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 276:1319.
Flynn E. (2008) Investigating children as cultural magnets: Do young children transmit redundant information along diffusion chains? Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 363(1509):3541.
Francis L. J., Gibson H. M. & Robbins M. (2001) God images and self-worth among adolescents in Scotland. Mental Health, Religion, and Culture 4:103108.
Frank R. H. (1988) Passions within reason. Norton.
Furnham A. (2003) Belief in a just world: Research progress over the past decade. Personality and Individual Differences 34(5):795–17.
Gervais W. M. & Norenzayan A. (2012b) Reminders of secular authority reduce believers' distrust of atheists. Psychological Science 23:483–91.
Gervais W. M. & Norenzayan A. (2013) Religion and the origins of anti-atheist prejudice. In: Intolerance and conflict: A scientific and conceptual investigation, ed. Clarke S., Powell R. & Savulescu J., pp. 126–45. Oxford University Press.
Guzman R. A., Rodriguez-Sickert C. & Rowthorn R. (2007) When in Rome, do as the Romans do: The coevolution of altruistic punishment, conformist learning, and cooperation. Evolution and Human Behavior 28:112–17.
Hamilton W. D. (1975) Innate social aptitudes of man: An approach from evolutionary genetics. In: Biosocial anthropology, ed. Fox R., pp. 133–53. Malaby Press.
Harris P., Pasquini E. S., Duke S., Asscher J. J. & Pons F. (2006) Germs and angels: The role of testimony in young children's ontology. Developmental Science 9(1):7696.
Harris P. L. & Koenig M. A. (2006) Trust in testimony: How children learn about science and religion. Child Development 77(3):505–24.
Harris S. (2005) The end of faith: Religion, terror and the future of reason. Norton.
Henrich J. (2004) Cultural group selection, coevolutionary processes and large-scale cooperation. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 53:325.
Henrich J. (2006) Cooperation, punishment, and the evolution of human institutions. Science 312:6061.
Henrich J. (2009) The evolution of costly displays, cooperation and religion: Credibility enhancing displays and their implications for cultural evolution. Evolution and Human Behavior 30:244–60.
Henrich J. (2015) The secret of our success: How learning from others drove human evolution, domesticated our species, and made us smart. Princeton University Press.
Henrich J. & Boyd R. (2002) On modeling cultural evolution: Why replicators are not necessary for cultural evolution. Journal of Cognition and Culture 2(2):87112.
Henrich J. & Boyd R. (2008) Division of labor, economic specialization, and the evolution of social stratification. Current Anthropology 49(4):715–24.
Henrich J., Boyd R. & Richerson P. J. (2008) Five misunderstandings about cultural evolution. Human Nature 19(2):119–37.
Henrich J., Boyd R. & Richerson P. J. (2012) The puzzle of monogamous marriage. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 367:657–66.
Henrich J., Ensimger J., McElreath R., Barr A., Barrett C., Bolyanatz A., Cardenas J., Gurven M., Gwako E., Henrich N., Lesorogol C., Marlowe F., Tracer D. & Ziker J. (2010a) Markets, religion, community size, and the evolution of fairness and punishment. Science 327:1480–84.
Henrich J. & Gil-White F. (2001) The evolution of prestige: Freely conferred deference as a mechanism for enhancing the benefits of cultural transmission. Evolution and Human Behavior 22(3):132, 165–96.
Henrich J. & Henrich N. (2014) Fairness without punishment: Behavioral experiments in the Yasawa Island, Fiji. In: Experimenting with social norms: Fairness and punishment in cross-cultural perspective, ed. Ensminger J. & Henrich J., pp. 225–58. Russell Sage Press.
Henrich N. & Henrich J. (2007) Why humans cooperate: A cultural and evolutionary explanation. Oxford University Press.
Herrmann B., Thoni C. & Gächter S. (2008) Antisocial punishment across societies. Science 319(5868):1362–67.
Herrmann P. A., Legare C. H., Harris P. L. & Whitehouse H. (2013) Stick to the script: The effect of witnessing multiple actors on children's imitation. Cognition 129:536–43.
Hopper L. M., Flynn E. G., Wood L. A. N. & Whiten A. (2010) Observational learning of tool use in children: Investigating cultural spread through diffusion chains and learning mechanisms through ghost displays. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 106(1):8297.
Hoppitt W. & Laland K. N. (2013) Social learning: An introduction to mechanisms, methods, and models. Princeton University Press.
Hruschka D., Efferson C., Jiang T., Falletta-Cowden A., Sigurdsson S., McNamara R., Sands M., Munira S., Slingerland E. & Henrich J. (2014) Impartial institutions, pathogen stress, and the expanding social network. Human Nature 25:567–79.
Hruschka D. & Henrich J. (2006) Friendship, cliquishness, and the emergence of cooperation. Journal of Theoretical Biology 239(1):115.
Ironson G., Stuetzle R., Ironson D., Balbin E., Kremer H., George A. & Fletcher M. A. (2011) View of god as benevolent and forgiving or punishing and judgmental predicts HIV disease progression. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 34:414–25.
Jaspers K. (1953) The origin and goal of history. Trans. Bullock M.. Yale University Press. (Original work, Vom Urspring und Ziel der Geschichte, published in 1949.)
Johnson K. A., Li Y. J., Cohen A. B. & Okun M. A. (2013) Friends in high places: The influence of authoritarian and benevolent God-concepts on social attitudes and behaviors. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality 5:1522.
Kant I. (1785/1964) Groundwork of the metaphysic of morals. Trans. Paton H. J.. Harper Torchbooks. (Original work published in 1785.)
Katz R. (1999) The straight path of the spirit: Ancestral wisdom and healing traditions in Fiji. Park Street Press.
Kay A. C., Whitson J. A., Gaucher D. & Galinsky A. D. (2009) Compensatory control: Achieving order through the mind, our institutions, and the heavens. Current Directions in Psychological Science 18:264–68. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8721.2009.01649.x.
Kelemen D. (2004) Are children “Intuitive Theists”? Reasoning about purpose and design in nature. Psychological Science 15:295301.
Keltner D., Kogan A., Piff P. K. & Saturn S. (2014) The sociocultural appraisals, values, and emotions (SAVE) framework of prosociality: Core processes from gene to meme. Annual Review of Psychology 65:425–60.
Kinzler K. D., Corriveau K. H. & Harris P. L. (2011) Children's selective trust in native-accented speakers. Developmental Science 14(1):106–11.
Kline M. A. (2015) How to learn about teaching: An evolutionary framework for the study of teaching behavior in humans and other animals. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 38.
Kline M. A., Boyd R. & Henrich J. (2013) Teaching and the life history of cultural transmission in Fijian villages. Human Nature 24(4):351–74.
Laland K. N. (2004) Social learning strategies. Learning and Behavior 32(1):414.
Laurin K., Kay A. C. & Fitzsimons G. M. (2012a) Divergent effects of activating thoughts of god on self-regulation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 102:421.
Laurin K., Shariff A. F., Henrich J. & Kay A. C. (2012b) Outsourcing punishment to God: Beliefs in divine control reduce earthly punishment. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 279:3272–81.
Lehmann L., Keller L., West S. & Roze D. (2007) Group selection and kin selection: Two concepts but one process. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104:6736–39.
Lopez D. S. (ed.) (2005) Critical terms for the study of Buddhism. University of Chicago Press.
McCullough M. E. & Willoughby B. L. B. (2009) Religion, self-regulation, and self-control: Associations, explanations, and implications. Psychological Bulletin 135:6993. doi: 10.1037/a0014213.
McElreath R. & Boyd R. (2007) Modeling the evolution of social behavior. Princeton University Press.
McNamara R. A. (2014) Powers interview: Sau, borisi, mana, sorcery, traditional medicine, totem beliefs in Yasawa, Fiji. unpublished raw data.
Mesoudi A. (2009) How cultural evolutionary theory can inform social psychology and vice versa. Psychological Review 116:929–52.
Miller J. H. & Page S. E. (2007) Complex adaptive systems: An introduction to computational models of social life (illustrated edition). Princeton University Press.
Morgan T. J. H. & Laland K. (2012) The biological bases of conformity. Frontiers in Neuroscience 6(87):17.
Morgan T. J. H., Rendell L. E., Ehn M., Hoppitt W. & Laland K. N. (2012) The evolutionary basis of human social learning. Proceedings of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 279(1729):653–62.
Moya C., Boyd R. & Henrich J. (in press) Reasoning about cultural and genetic transmission: Developmental and cross-cultural evidence from Peru, Fiji, and the US on how people make inferences about trait and identity transmission. Topics in Cognitive Science.
Nakahashi W., Wakano J. Y. & Henrich J. (2012) Adaptive social learning strategies in temporally and spatially varying environments how temporal versus spatial variation, number of cultural traits, and costs of learning influence the evolution of conformist-biased transmission, payoff-biased transmission, and individual learning. Human Nature 23(4):386–18.
Norenzayan A. (2013) Big Gods: How religion transformed cooperation and conflict. Princeton University Press.
Norenzayan A. (2015) Big questions about Big Gods: Response and discussion. Religion, Brain and Behavior 4:327–42.
Norenzayan A. (2016) Theodiversity. Annual Review of Psychology 67:21.121.24.
Norenzayan A., Dar-Nimrod I., Hansen I. G. & Proulx T. (2009) Mortality salience and religion: Divergent effects on the defense of cultural values for the religious and the non-religious. European Journal of Social Psychology 39:101–13.
Norenzayan A. & Gervais W. M. (2015) Secular rule of law erodes believers' political intolerance of atheists. Religion, Brain and Behavior 5:314.
Norenzayan A. & Hansen I. G. (2006) Belief in supernatural agents in the face of death. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 32:174–87.
Norris P. & Inglehart R. (2004) Sacred and secular: Religion and politics worldwide. Cambridge University Press.
Nowak M. A., Tarnita C. E. & Wilson E. O. (2010) The evolution of eusociality. Nature 466:1057–62.
Obeyesekere G. (2002) Imagining karma: Ethical transformation in Amerindian, Buddhist, and Greek rebirth. University of California Press.
Oishi S. & Diener E. (2014) Residents of poor nations have a greater sense of meaning in life than residents of wealthy nations. Psychological Science 25:422–30.
Payne R. K. & Tanaka K. K., eds. (2004) Approaching the land of bliss: Religious praxis in the cult of Amitåabha (No. 17). University of Hawaii Press.
Purzycki B. G. (2013) The minds of gods: A comparative study of supernatural agency. Cognition 129:163–79.
Purzycki B. G. & Arakchaa T. (2013) Ritual behavior and trust in the Tyva Republic. Current Anthropology 54:381–88.
Purzycki B. G., Haque O. & Sosis R. (2014) Extending evolutionary accounts of religion beyond the mind: Religions as adaptive systems. In: Evolution, religion, and cognitive science: Critical and constructive essays, ed. Watts F. & Turner L., pp. 7491. Oxford University Press.
Purzycki B. G. & McNamara R. A. (2016) An ecological theory of gods' minds. In: Advances in religion, cognitive science, and experimental philosophy, ed. Cruz H. De & Nichols R.. Bloomsbury.
Richerson P., Hillis V., Newson L., Baldini R., Frost K., Bell A., Demps K., Mathew S., Newton E., Narr N., Ross C., Smaldino P., Waring T. M. & Zefferman M. (in press) Cultural group selection plays an essential role in explaining human cooperation: A sketch of the evidence. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 38.
Sarkissian H. (2015) Supernatural, social, and self-monitoring in the scaling-up of Chinese civilization. Religion, Brain and Behavior 5:323–27.
Seabright P. (2004) The company of strangers: A natural history of economic life. Princeton University Press.
Shariff A. F. & Aknin L. B. (2014) The emotional toll of hell: Cross-national and experimental evidence for the negative well-being effects of Hell beliefs. PLOS ONE 9(1):e85251.
Shariff A. F. & Norenzayan A. (2007) God is watching you: Priming god concepts increases prosocial behavior in an anonymous economic game. Psychological Science 18:803809.
Shutts K., Kinzler K. D. & DeJesus J. M. (2013) Understanding infants' and children's social learning about foods: Previous research and new prospects. Developmental Psychology 49(3):419–25.
Sibley C. G. & Bulbulia J. (2012) Faith after an earthquake: A longitudinal study of religion and perceived health before and after the 2011 Christchurch, New Zealand earthquake. PLOS ONE 7:e49648. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049648.
Slingerland E. (2003) Confucius: Analects: With selections from traditional commentaries. Hackett.
Slingerland E. & Sullivan B. (in press) Durkheim with data: The database of religious history (DRH). Journal of the American Academy of Religion.
Smaldino P. E. (2014) The cultural evolution of emergent group-level traits. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 37:243–95.
Solt F., Habel P. & Grant J. T. (2011) Economic inequality, relative power, and religiosity. Social Science Quarterly 92:447–65.
Sosis R., Kress H. & Boster J. (2007) Scars for war: Evaluating alternative signaling explanations for cross-cultural variance in ritual costs. Evolution and Human Behavior 28:234–47.
Sperber D. (1996) Explaining culture: A naturalistic approach. Wiley-Blackwell.
Stark R. (1996) The rise of Christianity: How the obscure, marginal, Jesus movement became the dominant religious force. HarperOne.
Turchin P. (2005) War and peace and war: The life cycles of imperial nations. Pearson Education.
Turchin P. (2009) A theory for formation of large empires. Journal of Global History 4:191–17.
Turchin P. (2011) Warfare and the evolution of social complexity: A multilevel selection approach. Structure and Dynamics 4:137.
Tuzin D. (1976) The Ilahita Arapesh. University of California.
Tuzin D. (2001) Social complexity in the making: A case study among the Arapesh of New Guinea. Routledge.
Watts J., Greenhill S. J., Atkinson Q. D., Currie T. E., Bulbulia J. & Gray R. D. (2015) Broad supernatural punishment but not moralizing high gods precede the evolution of political complexity in Austronesia. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 282(1804). doi: 10.1098/rspb.2014.2556.
Whitehouse H. (1995) Inside the cult: Religious innovation and transmission in Papua New Guinea. Oxford University Press.
Wiessner P. (2002) The vines of complexity. Current Anthropology 43:233–69.
Wiessner P. & Tumu A. (1998) Historical vines. Smithsonian Institution Press.
Willard A. K. & Norenzayan A. (2013) Cognitive biases explain religious belief, paranormal belief, and belief in life's purpose. Cognition 129:379–91. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2013.07.016.
Wilson D. S. & Wilson E. O. (2007) Rethinking the theoretical foundation of sociobiology. Quarterly Review of Biology 82:327–48.
Winans C. S. & Bassler B. L., eds. (2008) Chemical communication among bacteria. ASM Press.
Xygalatas D., Mitkidis P., Fischer R., Reddish P., Skewes J., Geertz A. W., Roepstorff A. & Bulbulia J. (2013) Extreme rituals promote prosociality. Psychological Science 24:1602–605.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 13
Total number of PDF views: 102 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 389 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 16th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.