Skip to main content

Predicting the effect of rotation design on N, P, K balances on organic farms using the NDICEA model

  • Laurence G. Smith (a1) (a2), Davide Tarsitano (a3), Cairistiona F. E. Topp (a3), Stephanie K. Jones (a3), Catherine L. Gerrard (a1), Bruce D. Pearce (a1), Adrian G. Williams (a2) and Christine A. Watson (a4)...

The dynamic model Nitrogen Dynamics in Crop rotations in Ecological Agriculture (NDICEA) was used to assess the nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) balance of long-term organic cropping trials and typical organic crop rotations on a range of soil types and rainfall zones in the UK. The measurements of soil N taken at each of the organic trial sites were also used to assess the performance of NDICEA. The modeled outputs compared well to recorded soil N levels, with relatively small error margins. NDICEA therefore seems to be a useful tool for UK organic farmers. The modeling of typical organic rotations has shown that positive N balances can be achieved, although negative N balances can occur under high rainfall conditions and on lighter soil types as a result of leaching. The analysis and modeling also showed that some organic cropping systems rely on imported sources of P and K to maintain an adequate balance and large deficits of both nutrients are apparent in stockless systems. Although the K deficits could be addressed through the buffering capacity of minerals, the amount available for crop uptake will depend on the type and amount of minerals present, current cropping and fertilization practices and the climatic environment. A P deficit represents a more fundamental problem for the maintenance of crop yields and the organic sector currently relies on mined sources of P which represents a fundamental conflict with the International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements organic principles.

Corresponding author
* Corresponding author:
Hide All
ADAS. 2006. Assessing the sustainability of a stockless arable organic rotation. Defra Project OF0318. ADAS UK Ltd, UK.
Altieri M., Companioni N., Cañizares K., Murphy C., Rosset P., Bourque M., and Nicholls C. 1999. The greening of the “barrios”: Urban agriculture for food security in Cuba. Agriculture and Human Values 16:131140.
Andrist-Rangel Y., Edwards A., Hillier S., and Öborn I. 2007. Long-term K dynamics in organic and conventional mixed cropping systems as related to management and soil properties. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 122:413426.
Andrist-Rangel Y., Hillier S., Öborn I., Lilly A., Towers W., Edwards A.C., and Paterson E. 2010. Assessing potassium reserves in northern temperate grassland soils: A perspective based on quantitative mineralogical analysis and aqua-regia extractable potassium. Geoderma 158:303314.
Aronsson H., Torstensson G., and Bergström L. 2007. Leaching and crop uptake of N, P and K from organic and conventional cropping systems on a clay soil. Soil Use and Management 23:7181.
Bar-Yosef B., Magen H., Johnston A.E., and Kirkby E.A. 2015. Potassium fertilization: Paradox or K management dilemma? Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 30:115119.
Bergström L., Kirchmann H., Aronsson H., Torstensson G., and Mattsson L. 2008. Use efficiency and leaching of nutrients in organic and conventional cropping systems in Sweden. In Kirchmann H. and Bergström L. (eds.). Organic Crop Production–Ambitions and Limitations. Springer, Dordrecht. p. 143159.
Berry P.M., Sylvester-Bradley R., Philipps L., Hatch D.J., Cuttle S.P., Rayns F.W., and Gosling P. 2002. Is the productivity of organic farms restricted by the supply of available nitrogen? Soil Use and Management 18:248255.
Berry P., Stockdale E., Sylvester-Bradley R., Philipps L., Smith K., Lord E., Watson C., and Fortune S. 2003. N, P and K budgets for crop rotations on nine organic farms in the UK. Soil Use and Management 19:112118.
Buckman H.O. and Brady N.C. 1984. The Nature and Properties of Soils. 9th ed. Macmillan, New York, NY.
Cassman K.G., Dobermann A., and Walters D.T. 2002. Agroecosystems, nitrogen-use efficiency, and nitrogen management. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 31:132140.
Cordell D., Drangert J.-O., and White S. 2009. The story of phosphorus: global food security and food for thought. Global Environmental Change 19:292305.
Cormack W.F. 2006. Crop performance in a stockless arable organic rotation in eastern England. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 24:120.
Cox T., Bender M., Picone C., Tassel D.V., Holland J., Brummer E., Zoeller B., Paterson A., and Jackson W. 2002. Breeding perennial grain crops. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 21:5991.
Darnhofer I. 2005. Organic farming and rural development: Some evidence from Austria. Sociologia Ruralis 45:308323.
Dawson J.C., Huggins D.R., and Jones S.S. 2008. Characterizing nitrogen use efficiency in natural and agricultural ecosystems to improve the performance of cereal crops in low-input and organic agricultural systems. Field Crops Research 107:89101.
de Ponti T., Rijk B., and van Ittersum M.K. 2012. The crop yield gap between organic and conventional agriculture. Agricultural Systems 108:19.
Dekker S.E.M., de Boer I.J.M., Vermeij I., Aarnink A.J.A., and Koerkamp P.W.G.G. 2011. Ecological and economic evaluation of Dutch egg production systems. Livestock Science 139:109121.
Di H. and Cameron K. 2002. Nitrate leaching in temperate agroecosystems: Sources, factors and mitigating strategies. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 64:237256.
Döring T., Baddeley J., Hatch D., Marshall A., Pearce B., Roderick S., Stobart R., Storkey J., Watson C., and Wolfe M. 2013. Using Legume-Based Mixtures to Enhance the Nitrogen use Efficiency and Economic Viability of Cropping Systems. Home Grown Cereals Authority, Kenilworth.
Edwards A.C., Walker R.L., Maskell P., Watson C.A., Rees R.M., Stockdale E.A., and Knox O.G. 2010. Improving bioavailability of phosphate rock for organic farming. In Lichtfouse E. (ed.). Genetic Engineering, Biofertilisation, Soil Quality and Organic Farming. Springer, Dordrecht. p. 99117
El-Hage Scialabba N. and Müller-Lindenlauf M. 2010. Organic agriculture and climate change. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 25:11.
European Council. 2007. Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007 of 28 June 2007 on organic production and labelling of organic products and repealing Regulation (EEC) No 2092/91. European Commission, Brussels.
Francis C. and Porter P. 2011. Ecology in sustainable agriculture practices and systems. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 30:6473.
Gattinger A., Muller A., Haeni M., Skinner C., Fliessbach A., Buchmann N., Mäder P., Stolze M., Smith P., and Scialabba N.E.-H. 2012. Enhanced top soil carbon stocks under organic farming. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 109:1822618231.
Gaudin A., Westra S., Loucks C.E., Janovicek K., Martin R.C., and Deen W. 2013. Improving resilience of northern field crop systems using inter-seeded red clover: A review. Agronomy 3:148180.
Germer J., Addai S., and Sauerborn J. 2011. Response of grain sorghum to fertilisation with human urine. Field Crops Research 122:234241.
Godfray H. 2014. The challenge of feeding 9–10 billion people equitably and sustainably. Journal of Agricultural Science 152:17.
Gomiero T., Pimentel D., and Paoletti M.G. 2011. Environmental impact of different agricultural management practices: Conventional vs. organic agriculture. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 30:95124.
Greenland D.J. 1997. The Sustainability of Rice Farming. CAB International, Wallingford.
Haggar R. and Padel S. 1996. Conversion to Organic Milk Production (Defra Project OF0103). University of Wales Aberystwyth, Aberystwyth.
Hansen B., Kristensen E.S., Grant R., Høgh-Jensen H., Simmelsgaard S.E., and Olesen J.E. 2000. Nitrogen leaching from conventional versus organic farming systems—a systems modelling approach. European Journal of Agronomy 13:6582.
Hinsinger P., Dufey J., and Jaillard B. 1991. Biological weathering of micas in the rhizosphere as related to potassium absorption by plant roots. In McMichael B. and Persson H. (eds.). Plant Roots and Their Environment. Elsevier, Amsterdam. p. 98105.
Hoffland E., Giesler R., Jongmans T., and Van Breemen N. 2002. Increasing feldspar tunneling by fungi across a north Sweden podzol chronosequence. Ecosystems 5:1122.
Holmqvist J., Øgaard A.F., Öborn I., Edwards A., Mattsson L., and Sverdrup H. 2003. Application of the PROFILE model to estimate potassium release from mineral weathering in Northern European agricultural soils. European Journal of Agronomy 20:149163.
International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM). 2006. IFOAM Organic Principles. IFOAM, Bonn.
Johnston A.E., Poulton P.R., and Coleman K. 2009. Soil organic matter: its importance in sustainable agriculture and carbon dioxide fluxes. In Sparks D. (ed.). Advances in Agronomy. Academic Press, San Diego, CA. p. 157.
Jørgensen K.F. and Kristensen E. 2010. Fælles Strategi for Udfasning af Konventionel Gødning og halm i økologisk Landbrugsproduktion [Common Strategy for the Phasing Out of Manure and Straw in Organic Agriculture]. Organic Denmark and Danish Agriculture and Food Council, Copenhagen.
Kaffka S. and Koepf H.H. 1989. A case study on the nutrient regime in sustainable farming. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 6:89106.
Karak T. and Bhattacharyya P. 2011. Human urine as a source of alternative natural fertilizer in agriculture: A flight of fancy or an achievable reality. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 55:400408.
Khan S., Mulvaney R., and Ellsworth T. 2014. The potassium paradox: Implications for soil fertility, crop production and human health. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 29:327.
Khan S., Mulvaney R., Ellsworth T., and Boast C. 2007. The myth of nitrogen fertilization for soil carbon sequestration. Journal of Environmental Quality 36:18211832.
Kirchmann H., Bergström L., Kätterer T., Mattsson L., and Gesslein S. 2007. Comparison of long-term organic and conventional crop–livestock systems on a previously nutrient-depleted soil in Sweden. Agronomy Journal 99:960972.
Kirchmann H., Kätterer T., and Bergström L. 2008. Nutrient supply in organic agriculture. In Kirchmann H. and Bergström L. (eds.). Organic Crop Production—Ambitions and Limitations. Springer, Dordrecht. p. 89116.
Korsaeth A. 2012. N, P, and K budgets and changes in selected topsoil nutrients over 10 yr in a long-term experiment with conventional and organic crop rotations. Applied and Environmental Soil Science 2012:17.
Lampkin N. 2002. Organic Farming. Old Pond Publishing, Ipswich.
Lampkin N., Measures M., and Padel S. 2011. 2011/12 Organic Farm Management Handbook. The Organic Research Centre, Elm Farm, Newbury.
Le Gal P.Y., Dugué P., Faure G., and Novak S. 2011. How does research address the design of innovative agricultural production systems at the farm level? A review. Agricultural Systems 104:714728.
Lennartsson M. 2000. Conversion to Organic Field Vegetable Production (Defra Project OF0126 T). Garden Organic, Ryton.
Liang X., Xu L., Li H., He M., Qian Y., Liu J., Nie Z., Ye Y., and Chen Y. 2011. Influence of N fertilization rates, rainfall, and temperature on nitrate leaching from a rainfed winter wheat field in Taihu watershed. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 36:395400.
Loes A.K. and Øgaard A.F. 1997. Changes in the nutrient content of agricultural soil on conversion to organic farming in relation to farm-level nutrient balances and soil contents of clay and organic matter. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section B—Soil and Plant Science 47:201214.
Luske B. and van der Kamp J. 2009. Carbon Sequestration Potential of Reclaimed Desert Soils in Egypt. Louis Bolk Institute Driebergen and Soil and More International, Waddinxveen.
Melillo J.M., Aber J.D., Linkins A.E., Ricca A., Fry B., and Nadelhoffer K.J. 1989. Carbon and nitrogen dynamics along the decay continuum: Plant litter to soil organic matter. Plant and Soil 115:189198.
Mengel K., and Rahmatullah D.H. 1998. Release of potassium from the silt and sand fraction of loess-derived soils. Soil Science 163:805813.
Moakes S. and Lampkin N. 2010. Organic Farm Incomes in England and Wales 2008/09 (Defra Project OF0373). University of Wales Aberystwyth, Aberystwyth and The Organic Research Centre, Newbury.
Moakes S. and Lampkin N. 2011. Organic Farm Incomes in England and Wales 2009/10 (Defra Project OF0373). University of Wales Aberystwyth, Aberystwyth and The Organic Research Centre, Newbury.
Moakes S., Lampkin N., and Gerrard C.L. 2012. Organic Farm Incomes in England and Wales 2010/11 (Defra Project OF0373). University of Wales Aberystwyth, Aberystwyth and The Organic Research Centre, Newbury.
Möller K. 2009a. Influence of different manuring systems with and without biogas digestion on soil organic matter and nitrogen inputs, flows and budgets in organic cropping systems. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 84:179202.
Möller K. and Stinner W. 2009b. Effects of different manuring systems with and without biogas digestion on soil mineral nitrogen content and on gaseous nitrogen losses (ammonia, nitrous oxides). European Journal of Agronomy 30:116.
Mulvaney R.L., Khan S.A., and Ellsworth T.R. 2009. Synthetic nitrogen fertilizers deplete soil nitrogen. A global dilemma for sustainable cereal production. Journal of Environmental Quality 38:22952314.
Nowak B., Nesme T., David C., and Pellerin S. 2013. To what extent does organic farming rely on nutrient inflows from conventional farming? Environmental Research Letters 8:044045.
Oelofse M., Høgh-Jensen H., Abreu L.S., Almeida G.F., El-Araby A., Hui Q.Y., and de Neergaard A. 2010. A comparative study of farm nutrient budgets and nutrient flows of certified organic and non-organic farms in China, Brazil and Egypt. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 87:455470.
Oelofse M., Jensen L., and Magid J. 2013. The implications of phasing out conventional nutrient supply in organic agriculture: Denmark as a case. Organic Agriculture 3:4155.
Patil R.H., Laegdsmand M., Olesen J.E., and Porter J.R. 2010. Effect of soil warming and rainfall patterns on soil N cycling in northern Europe. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 139:195205.
Pimentel D., Cerasale D., Stanley R.C., Perlman R., Newman E.M., Brent L.C., Mullan A., and Chang D.T.-I. 2012. Annual vs. perennial grain production. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 161:19.
Pretty J.N., Noble A.D., Bossio D., Dixon J., Hine R.E., Penning de Vries F.W.T., and Morison J.I.L. 2005. Resource-conserving agriculture increases yields in developing countries. Environmental Science and Technology 40:11141119.
Robinson K.G., Robinson C.H., Raup L.A., and Markum T.R. 2012. Public attitudes and risk perception toward land application of biosolids within the south-eastern United States. Journal of Environmental Management 98:2936.
Schmutz U., Rayns F., and Firth C. 2007. Balancing fertility management and economics in organic field vegetable rotations. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 87:27912793.
Seufert V., Ramankutty N., and Foley J.A. 2012. Comparing the yields of organic and conventional agriculture. Nature 485:229232.
Simonsson M., Andersson S., Andrist-Rangel Y., Hillier S., Mattsson L., and Öborn I. 2007. Potassium release and fixation as a function of fertilizer application rate and soil parent material. Geoderma 140:188198.
Smith K., Beckwith C., Chalmers A., and Jackson D. 2002. Nitrate leaching following autumn and winter application of animal manures to grassland. Soil Use and Management 18:428434.
Smith L.G., Williams A.G., and Pearce B.D. 2015. The energy efficiency of organic agriculture: A review. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 30:280301.
Smith S. 2009. Organic contaminants in sewage sludge (biosolids) and their significance for agricultural recycling. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 367:40054041.
Snapp S.S., Swinton S.M., Labarta R., Mutch D., Black J.R., Leep R., Nyiraneza J., and O'Neil K. 2005. Evaluating cover crops for benefits, costs and performance within cropping system niches. Agronomy Journal 97:322332.
Stinner W., Möller K., and Leithold G. 2008. Effects of biogas digestion of clover/grass-leys, cover crops and crop residues on nitrogen cycle and crop yield in organic stockless farming systems. European Journal of Agronomy 29:125134.
Taylor B., Younie D., Matheson S., Coutts M., Mayer C., Watson C., and Walker R. 2006. Output and sustainability of organic ley/arable crop rotations at two sites in northern Scotland. Journal of Agricultural Science 144:435447.
Torstensson G., Aronsson H., and Bergström L. 2006. Nutrient use efficiencies and leaching of organic and conventional cropping systems in Sweden. Agronomy Journal 98:603615.
Trydeman Knudsen M., Sillebak Kristensen I., Berntsen J., Molt Petersen B., and Steen Kristensen E. 2006. Estimated N leaching losses for organic and conventional farming in Denmark. Journal of Agricultural Science 144:135149.
Valdivia C., Barbieri C., and Gold M.A. 2012. Between forestry and farming: Policy and environmental implications of the barriers to agroforestry adoption. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie 60:155175.
Van der Burgt G.J. and Rietberg P. 2012. Enhancement of the NDICEA Decision Support Tool for Reducing N Losses in Commercial Farming. In WP2, Deliverable 2.6, EC Framework 7 project N-TOOLBOX, KBBE-2008–1-2-08. L.D. Louis Bolk Institute, Driebergen.
Van der Burgt G., Oomen G., Habets A., and Rossing W. 2006. The NDICEA model, a tool to improve nitrogen use efficiency in cropping systems. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 74:275294.
Verhoeven F., Reijs J., and Van Der Ploeg J. 2003. Re-balancing soil-plant-animal interactions: Towards reduction of nitrogen losses. NJAS-Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences 51:147164.
Watson C., Younie D., Stockdale E., Cormack W., Cook S., Green M., Holland J., Leake A., and Welsh J. 2000. Yields and nutrient balances in stocked and stockless organic rotations in the UK. Aspects of Applied Biology 62:261268.
Watson C.A., Atkinson D., Gosling P., Jackson L.R., and Rayns F.W. 2002. Managing soil fertility in organic farming systems. Soil Use and Management 18:239247.
Watson C., Öborn I., Eriksen J., and Edwards A. 2005. Perspectives on nutrient management in mixed farming systems. Soil Use and Management 21:8.
Watson C., Baddeley J., Edwards A., Rees R., Walker R., and Topp C. 2011. Influence of ley duration on the yield and quality of the subsequent cereal crop (spring oats) in an organically managed long-term crop rotation experiment. Organic Agriculture 1:147159.
Webb J., Pain B., Bittman S., and Morgan J. 2010. The impacts of manure application methods on emissions of ammonia, nitrous oxide and on crop response—A review. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 137:3946.
Welsh J.P., Philipps L., and Cormack W.F. 2002. The long-term agronomic performance of organic stockless rotations. In Powell J. (ed.). Proceedings of the UK Organic Research Conference. Organic Centre Wales. University of Wales Aberystwyth, Aberystwyth. p. 4750.
Wilkins R. 2008. Eco-efficient approaches to land management: A case for increased integration of crop and animal production systems. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 363:517525.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems
  • ISSN: 1742-1705
  • EISSN: 1742-1713
  • URL: /core/journals/renewable-agriculture-and-food-systems
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 90 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 307 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 16th January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.