We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Assessment of the risks and benefits of genetic and genomic tests has long been addressed using ad hoc evaluation methods. They are mostly ACCE-based, focus on technical aspects, and often overlook economic and organizational considerations. The few health technology assessment (HTA) based approaches, though more comprehensive, lack validation and implementation. This review’s purpose was to identify evaluation frameworks for genetic and genomic tests and to synthesize their key aspects.
Methods
PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Google Search were used to identify records describing any assessment framework for genetic or genomic tests. As this was an update of a previous systematic review, the search was restricted to records published from 1 October 2020. Inclusion criteria were documents describing evaluation frameworks for genetic or genomic tests that were original, specifically created, and covered at least three evaluation components (analytic validity, clinical validity, clinical utility, economic aspects, or ethical, legal, and social implications). This study was supported by the European Commission and the Ministry for Universities and Research under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (M4C2-I1.3 Project PE_00000019 “HEAL ITALIA”).
Results
Overall, 22,862 records were retrieved and 12,546 unique records were screened, of which 67 documents were assessed for eligibility. However, none of these met the inclusion criteria and no additional framework was found. In contrast, a total of 37 studies reporting 30 different frameworks were included from the previous systematic review. The analysis of these frameworks revealed that they were published between 2000 and 2019 and were mostly based on the ACCE model (n=13), on the HTA process (n=6), or both (n=3). Others referred to the Wilson and Jungner screening criteria (n=3) or to a mixture of different criteria (n=5).
Conclusions
A pressing need exists for a universally accepted evaluation framework for genetic and genomic tests. A shift from ad hoc assessments to a general HTA methodology, potentially based on the EUnetHTA Core Model®, is needed. By integrating solid theoretical and methodological principles, a validated, comprehensive, and widely shared tool for evaluating genetic tests can be realized, promoting consistency across Europe and beyond.
Frameworks based on the ACCE model, which have a limited health technology assessment (HTA) approach, have long been used in the assessment of genetic and genomic applications (GGAs). While ACCE frameworks are mainly focused on technical aspects, HTA assessments include economic and organizational aspects. The aim of this study was to develop a framework able to address a comprehensive assessment of GGAs.
Methods
We analyzed the most currently used HTA model in Europe, the EUnetHTA HTA Core Model®, to investigate its suitability as an HTA framework for GGAs and to identify any possible shortcomings in its evaluation. The Sapienza evaluation framework, which is based on a previous systematic review of assessment frameworks for GGAs, was used as the comparison. The HTA Core Model applications were then used as a basis for an assessment framework for GGAs, classified according to “GGA function/use setting” pairs.
Results
The domains included in the Sapienza framework fully corresponded with the HTA Core Model. In addition, the “Screening Technology” application of the HTA Core Model was found to be suitable for diagnostic, pre-symptomatic, predictive, and carrier GGAs when used in screening settings. The “Diagnostic Technologies” application was deemed appropriate for the pairs “Diagnostic/Diagnosis”, “Pre-symptomatic/Diagnosis”, “Prognostic/Staging”, and “Pharmacogenetic/Staging”, although it may require additional considerations such as the need for screening in the case of germline mutations, the use of appropriate accuracy measures for prognostic GGAs, and the evaluation of the clinical utility of pharmacogenetic or prognostic GGAs.
Conclusions
The proposed approach is a flexible tool that allows assessment of GGAs using a shared and validated methodology that considers the technical aspect, clinical utility, economic value, and delivery models. We found that the HTA Core Model fits the needs of GGA assessment, although some GGA peculiarities should be further explored in the assessment process.
Bipolar disorder in children is characterized by a different course than in adults, which is a diagnostic difficulty. DAT-1 is a dopamine transporter gene that regulates dopaminergic neurotransmission through the mechanism of active reuptake of this neurotransmitter from the synapse. Polymorphisms within the described gene can result in changes in dopamine levels, which may have implications for the development of bipolar disorder.
Objectives
The aim of the project was to analyze the relationship between single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) within the dopamine transporter gene DAT-1 and the risk of development of bipolar disorder in a population of children and adolescents.
Methods
21 healthy controls (12 females, 9 males) have been recruited into the study and 13 patients (9 girls, 4 boys) with bipolar disorder diagnosis from Department of Psychiatry and outpatient clinic, were recruited for the study group. Questionnaires such as the KSADS-PL were carried out and blood was taken for laboratory tests of four SNPs within the DAT-1 transporter. PQStat, Microsoft Excel 2013 and StatSoft STATISTICA were used to perform the statistical analysis.
Results
SNPs within the dopamine transporter gene and environmental risk factors influenced the risk of developing bipolar disorder in the population of children and adolescents.
Conclusions
The ambiguity in results emphasizes the necessity for further investigations into correlation between genetic factors in bipolar disorder etiology. Future research should involve more participants. The results of this project are likely to make a significant and valuable contribution to the current knowledge of bipolar disorder and to the development of innovative diagnostic methods, making a significant contribution to the advancement of science.
Down’s syndrome often requires specialized rehabilitation methods in order to effectively improve cognitive and motor functioning. The growing interest in technologies to support rehabilitation is opening up new and promising perspectives for improving the quality of life of people diagnosed with this syndrome. One of these technologies is the Computer Assisted Rehabilitation Environment (CAREN) system from Motek.
Objectives
The aim of the planned research project is to explore the potential of using the CAREN system in the rehabilitation of people with Down’s syndrome.
Methods
The study included 10 participants with Down’s syndrome (men and women aged 18 to 50 years) without the presence of organic musculoskeletal disease or other somatic causes impairing motor performance. Before the training test, the participants were assessed by two psychological tests: 1) ACE III - Addenbrooke’s Cognitive Examination III Scale (ACE-III), which assesses attention and orientation, memory, verbal fluency, language and visuospatial functions and 2) the TONI 4 Non-Verbal Intelligence Test, which is a test used to measure general intelligence. The tests were carried out using the MOTEK CAREN device, which consists of a treadmill for motor training and a virtual reality screen on which different scenes are displayed for the participant to see during the test. Integrated motion capture technology was used to assess movement capabilities of the patients.. The screen displayed different types of applications in the form of virtual reality, in which the participant had to cope with various tasks accommodating different psychomotor skills, for example:crossing a virtual bridge, walking through a forest. The test took about 45 minutes per person. Two training sessions were conducted for each of the 10 patients with a one-month interval between them.
Results
The Motek Caren System has proven to be a promising rehabilitation method for people with Down’s syndrome, compared to previous experience with different rehabilitation methods and existing research in the field.
Conclusions
Results emphasize the necessity for further investigations and future research should involve more participants. The project has the potential to integrate modern technology with traditional forms of therapy to improve the quality of life and functioning of people affected by this syndrome.
The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has resulted in a significant influx of refugees seeking asylum in other countries, including Poland. Among these refugees are individuals who are struggling with mental health issues. Polish psychiatrists have stepped up to provide care for these patients, despite facing a number of challenges in the process.
Objectives
This presentation aims to shed light on the experiences of Polish psychiatrists treating refugees during the war in Ukraine, highlighting the difficulties they have encountered and the strategies they have employed to provide the best possible care to their patients. The presentation also examines the impact of war on mental health, and the long-term effects on the well-being of refugees.
Methods
A questionnaire study was done among Polish Psychiatrists about the forms of support they provided for Ukrainin psychiatric patients they consulted after 24 February 2022. The responses to questionnaires were collected during psychiatric Congresses.
Results
The most commonly reported symptoms were anxiety (44.1%), followed by depression (35.3%), and panic attacks (23.5%). Other symptoms like irritability and sleep disorders were reported by 11.8% and 8.8% of the respondents, respectively. Disturbingly, thoughts of resignation and suicidal ideation were also reported, albeit at lower frequencies (8.8% and 2.9%, respectively). A small percentage (2.9%) reported no new symptoms.
The high prevalence of anxiety and depression suggests that the war has had a profound impact on the mental health of the affected population. The emergence of severe symptoms like psychotic thoughts and suicidal ideation, although less frequent, is alarming and calls for immediate intervention. It is also noteworthy that a small but significant portion of the population reported no new symptoms, which may indicate resilience or other coping mechanisms at play.
Conclusions
The war in Ukraine has led to a range of new psychological symptoms among the affected populations, with anxiety, depression, and panic attacks being the most prevalent. Immediate and long-term psychological interventions are urgently needed to address these emerging mental health issues. Further research is also required to understand the resilience factors among those who reported no new symptoms.
Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is associated with worse outcomes in stroke, Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and Parkinson’s disease (PD), but diagnosis is challenging in these groups. We aimed to compare the prevalence of high risk of OSA based on commonly used questionnaires and self-reported OSA diagnosis: 1. within groups with stroke, AD, PD and the general population (GP); 2. Between neurological groups and GP.
Methods:
Individuals with stroke, PD and AD were identified in the Canadian Longitudinal Study of Aging (CLSA) by survey. STOP, STOP-BAG, STOP-B28 and GOAL screening tools and OSA self-report were compared by the Chi-squared test. Logistic regression was used to compare high risk/self-report of OSA, in neurological conditions vs. GP, adjusted for confounders.
Results:
We studied 30,097 participants with mean age of 62.3 years (SD 10.3) (stroke n = 1791; PD n = 175; AD n = 125). In all groups, a positive GOAL was the most prevalent, while positive STOP was least prevalent among questionnaires. Significant variations in high-risk OSA were observed between different questionnaires across all groups. Under 1.5% of individuals self-reported OSA. While all questionnaires suggested a higher prevalence of OSA in stroke than the GP, for PD and AD, there was heterogeneity depending on questionnaire.
Conclusions:
The wide range of prevalences of high risk of OSA resulting from commonly used screening tools underscores the importance of validating them in older adults with neurological disorders. OSA was self-reported in disproportionately small numbers across groups, suggesting that OSA is underdiagnosed in older adults or underreported by patients, which is concerning given its increasingly recognized impact on brain health.
This book is inspired by the quest for the proper function of Aristotle's active intellect presented in De Anima 3.5. The urge to grasp its essence has always driven philosophy ahead. Nevertheless, the true nature of nous poiêtikos remains far from being grasped. The author did not unravel it here either, her aim was far more modest: to get through the existing interpretations and try to systematise them somehow. To speak in a more poetic, metaphorical way: the author's aim was to shed some light upon the subject - explore the light metaphor from De Anima 3.5 on many levels. To avoid getting lost in Aristotle and Aristotelian interpretations, the author divided the readings of nous poiêtikos into mystical and rational ones.
This chapter discusses from three perspectives the stages of the hybridity of writing systems in the period of the formation of various alphabets as well as their adaptations to the requirements of specific languages. Firstly, the chapter draws attention to the role of borrowings and intersystemic influences at the early stage of the formation of the ‘grand’ alphabets, including the Greek, Latin Cyrillic and Arabic alphabets. These are forms of writing of a long tradition, which later became the basis for numerous national alphabets. Adaptations which adjust a certain alphabetic system (the base alphabet) to the needs of writing the phones of a different language constitute the second – narrower – perspective on contacts between alphabets and the transformations within them. The reflections in this part are exemplified by references to the Latin alphabet in its Polish edition. The chapter then focuses on the narrowest perspective, drawing readers’ attention to alphabet adaptations that did not achieve the status of national writing. This is exemplified by two – entirely different – models of adaptation, comprising the Polish graždanka (Polish Cyrillic alphabet) and the Polish and Belarusian Arabic-graphic writing (aljamiado). Additionally, the author briefly discusses Polish texts written in the Armenian alphabet.
According to the Journal of Laws of the Republic of Poland, juveniles considered to be socially maladjusted are referred to the facilities called Youth Educational Centres. The aforementioned decision must be processed by court. Adolescents held there are guilty mainly of truancy, acts of vandalism, and the crime of theft. Other reasons might include substance abuse, fleeing from home and loitering without legal guardian’s supervision. The key purpose behind those institutions is adjusting to social standards, as well as rehabilitation of each juvenile delinquent. On the other hand, such behaviors may result from various mental disorders, which are often overlooked and underestimated.
Objectives
The aim of this study was to assess the prevalence of psychiatric disorders among the inmates of Youth Educational Centres with a primary Focus on bipolar disorder. The existing knowledge on this subject is insufficient whereas the only available papers are based on retrospective studies of documents, which may have led to underestimation of mental condition in this population.
Methods
Patients were examined in person, using the K-SADS diagnostic interview. The missing details were also collected during reviewing the inmates’ documents. The study group consists of juveniles staying in two Youth Educational Centres, a male and female one, located in Silesian Province of southern Poland. Participation in the research was voluntary whereas information gathered during the interview remains confidential.
Results
The study included 80 adolescents who previously had consented to participate. 60% (n=48) of them were males. Among the male patients 27.08% met the criteria for an episode of mania/hypomania, 37.5% for a depressive disorder whereas 22.92% fulfilled the criteria for both mania and depression. Seven boys were diagnosed beforehand, those included: one case of bipolar disorder, one schizoaffective disorder and five of them were receiving outpatient treatment for depressive episodes. Among female inmates: 40.63% met the criteria for both mania/hypomania and depressive disorder whereas as many as 78.13% claimed to have depressive disorder. Two girls have already been diagnosed – one suffered from bipolar disorder, manic depression and schizophrenia and the other was treated for depressive episodes.
Conclusions
Social maladjustment is often accompanied by a mental disorder or may be caused by one. Psychiatric disorders in adolescents, particularly bipolar disorder, usually have an atypical course, which can delay the appropriate diagnosis. Postponement of the crucial treatment is directly related to significant deterioration of the patient’s prognosis. In order to provide adequate and necessary support, juveniles referred to the Youth Educational Centres should be examined by a certified psychiatrist before the admission to such facility.
Down syndrome (DS) is a complex condition that causes various health problems and it is accepted that treadmill training is a therapy method for some of them.
Objectives
The objective was to evaluate the effectiveness of various results of treadmill training in children and adults with DS.
Methods
We included studies in which participants with DS from every age group received treadmill training, alone or combined with physiotherapy and could optionally be compared to a control group with patients with DS who did not use treadmill training. The search was conducted in medical databases: PubMed, PEDro, Science Direct, Scopus and Web of Science and involved trials published until July 2021. Following PRISMA criteria, the Risk of Bias assessment was conducted using a tool developed by the Cochrane Collaboration for RCT. The included studies presented multiple outcomes and various methodologies therefore we were not able to conduct any sort of data synthesis, we presented measures of treatment effect as mean differences and corresponding 95% confidence intervals.
Results
5 studies with a total number of 687 participants were included. 10 trials reported on walking onset, 8 on gait parameters or cardiovascular functions, 4 on anti-inflammatory effect and 3 on executive or cognitive functions. We came across 25 different outcomes in different age groups which are presented in a narrative manner. In all outcomes we have observed a positive result favouring the treadmill training.
Conclusions
Introducing treadmill exercise into typical physiotherapy generates improvements of mental and physical health of people with DS of all ages.
Psychodrama and Drama therapy enable patients to establish contact with the threat of stepping into a given role. This gives the opportunity to learn how to control it, which leads to better expression of oneself and better communication with the environment. Those qualities are crucial in the treatment of mental disorders. Despite the variety of literature describing the methodology, clinical trials using these forms of therapy are relatively rare.
Objectives
To describe the current trends in psychodrama (PD) and drama (DT) research over the last 6 years.
Methods
We have implemented a systematic approach to literature review, consistent with the PRISMA declaration. We searched through major medical databases: PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus by Elsevier and Science Direct for peer-reviewed articles published between 2015 and 2020. We have included studies using all types of methodology: mixed, quantitative and qualitative and also case studies. The risk of bias was assessed for randomized clinical trials, consistent with the PRISMA declaration.
Results
Using our search strategy we have identified 24 publications with 454 participants. Most of the subjects were adults, only four studies focused on children. Overall, these studies looked at the effects of PD i DT on more than 25 different outcomes. Therefore theatre - based therapies research reports promising results across all methodologies. Although, most of the interventions have small groups of clients and are not randomized.
Conclusions
Current reports on the effectiveness of PD and DT still need to be verified on a larger group of patients.
In one way or another, crisis has always been a part of our lives and it is still a central aspect of contemporary world, ridden by recurring economic, environmental, and health threats. Faces of Crisis in 20th- and 21st-Century Prose. An Anthology of Criticism offers a unique overview of the motif of crisis tackled by 20th- and 1st-century writers.
'The main value of this anthology lies in its unique array of perspectives. The contributors focus on literary works which may have been analysed by other scholars, but never before have they been examined from the perspective of crisis and its different forms. Many of the discussed works were written, or rediscovered, in the last two decades. To the best of my knowledge, there is no other study like this volume.' From the review by Professor Aleksandra Kêdzierska, Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Lublin
Although 3.5 is the most cryptic chapter of De Anima, there are some controversies about 3.7 as well. I will sketch them briefly here. To this end I will use the paper by Klaus Corcilius ‘De Anima III 7: The Actuality Principle and the Triggering of Mental Episodes’ which – I hope – will enrich my current deliberations, especially when it comes to the issue of desire.
It is hard to see what Aristotle’s De Anima III 7 is about. The chapter starts out with a sentence that seems to be a verbatim quotation from DA III 5 while the rest seems to exhibit little thematic coherence, jumping back and forth between issues regarding sense perception, pleasure and pain, desire, and, perhaps predominantly, thought. It also seems that parts of the chapter discuss issues that have been previously discussed in the De Anima. There is certainly no obvious unifying theme in the text. This is why the chapter has puzzled interpreters from early on, some of whom openly admitted the lack of thematic unity. Most notably, Adolf Torstrik proposed a radical thesis. In his 1862 edition of the De Anima, he claimed that the chapter divides into 8 sections that lack any thematic unity whatsoever both with each other and with the preceding and the following chapters. He further claimed that in view of the heterogeneity of these sections, only a ‘very bad scribe (pessimum quidem scriptorem)’ could have put them together into one single chapter (the word he uses is ‘glued together’ conglutinare, p. XXV). Torstrik’s radical verdict was received rather favorably by later scholars. Thus, David Ross, in his widespread editions of the De Anima, accepted the verdict (while opting for a slightly different grouping of the sections), as did editors, translators and commentators such as Förster, Siwek, Theiler, and up until Christopher Shields in his recent translation and commentary. The resounding success of Torstrik’s claim is not difficult to explain. For he, apart from his brief argument for the thematic disunity of the chapter, provided also solid linguistic evidence to the effect that the parts of the chapter lack coherence even on a basic grammatical level.
If we made immortality the ultimate criterion, then I would bet on the mystics (despite all my criticism towards them, see for instance: my discussion with Caston or Burnyeat). Aristotle did not believe in individual immortality (endorsed by the rationalists), but in the immortality of the species (in biological terms). This, together with the non-theist account of the Deity, makes the mystical interpretations more appropriate. The Christian ones, despite being prevailing in our Western culture, are sometimes an ‘abuse’ of Aristotle or – broadly speaking – the ancient worldview. And although the vision of having an individual immortal soul that unites with God after our bodily death and retains its personality is nice and comforting (to some extent, because in most cases the soul is powerless and can do nothing, only ‘sit and watch’), it is very far from Aristotle. Moreover, Thomism, for instance, has this advantage over almost every reading of the Stagirite: that it is very coherent and fixes all the ‘holes’ in Aristotle. This is, I believe, one of the main reasons (besides the religious motivation) why Franz Brentano endorsed it. He claimed coherence to be the most important feature of a good interpretation. He was very much against incorporating foreign views or leaving some questions unanswered (which is what many scholars are forced to do while working on ancient thinkers). But it is here where I believe he made a mistake. First of all, Thomism does incorporate heterogenic views into Aristotelianism, creationism being the most vivid example of not only foreign, but also contradictory views. Rationalism simply comes at a bigger price … Second of all, Brentano embarked on a breakneck project to introduce an agreement between Theophrastus and Eudemus. However, instead of frankly admitting that there are both rational and mystical elements in Aristotle, he tried to show that Eudemus meant something else and thus bring him nearer to Theophrastus (whom he obviously preferred), and on this basis, he built his Christian interpretation. And this is what led him astray.
For now (and apart from my personal preference), let us accept a peaceful coexistence of rational and mystical elements in Aristotle.
Rational vs. Mystical Readings of Aristotle’s Nous Poiêtikos. Introduction to the Subject and Overview of Central Positions
One of the authors who inspired me to start the journey in search of nous poiêtikos’s proper function, besides Aristotle and Franz Brentano (to whom I have devoted a decade of research and whose Aristotelianism has shaped my thinking profoundly, although I often disagree with him), is Victor Caston. Caston – in his brilliant and provocative paper ‘Aristotle’s Two Intellects. A Modest Proposal’ – claims that nous poiêtikos has no proper function and thus does nothing. He calls the attempts to find this function ‘a wild goose chase’. Well … he may be right. However, it is not easy to come to terms with this (dis)solution. It is both bold and disturbing. Although it is designed to bring peace, it does not put my worries to sleep. And it makes me want to dig deeper. Thus, I am embarking on this project full of hope and with a strong conviction that it is all about the journey and not (just) the destination. To avoid getting lost in Aristotle and Aristotelian interpretations, I have divided the readings of nous poiêtikos into mystical and rational ones. What inspired me here is Rolf George’s opinion, expressed in the introduction to his translation of Franz Brentano’s Habilitationsschrift: Die Psychologie des Aristoteles, insbesondere seine Lehre vom nous poietikos (1867). George claimed there that Brentano was against all the mystical elements and traces in the interpretation of Corpus Aristotelicum. Interestingly, Brentano does not explicitly declare war against mysticism and does not use this label in his Aristotelian writings (he does criticise mysticism as the phase of philosophy’s decay some time later, but it is a different mysticism though). George’s remark was pointed at Brentano’s lifelong discussion with Eduard Zeller (see, for instance, Aristoteles Lehre vom Ursprung des menschlichen Geistes). Interestingly, if one scrutinises all the philosophical theories denounced by Brentano in his Habilitationsschrift, one will clearly see that they have a lot in common. I borrow the name from George, and I call these views (and the contemporary, post-Brentanian ones that are somehow similar to them) ‘mystical’. Along these lines, I call the adherents of the opposite ones – ‘rationalists’.
Possible Readings of Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, Book X
Above, I presented two possible interpretations of the notorious active intellect whose proper function still remains uncertain. These were: (a) the mystical and (b) the rational one. According to (a) nous poiêtikos does not belong to a particular human being but is identical with Deity or a divine sphere. Moreover, humans are capable of a sort of mystical union with it and this is how they access and emulate the Deity. According to (b) nous poiêtikos belongs to us and through its activity we can learn about the Deity and strive after it. In both (a) and (b) there is a sort of an imperative to follow what is divine, in order to lead a good life. This is why I decided to examine which of these two viewpoints is more appropriate, by comparing the paths leading to such a life proposed by each of them. I decided to use the book X of Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics as a criterion. This is where the philosopher’s theoretical life finds its most famous description. Let us then begin with presenting the most important fragments thereof.
(I) If happiness is activity in accordance with virtue, it is reasonable that it should be in accordance with the highest virtue; and this will be that of the best thing in us. Whether it be reason or something else that is this element which is thought to be our natural ruler and guide and to take thought of things noble and divine, whether it be itself also divine or only the most divine element in us, the activity of this in accordance with its proper virtue will be perfect happiness. That this activity is contemplative we have already said. Now this would seem to be in agreement both with what we said before and with the truth. For, firstly, this activity is the best (since not only is reason the best thing in us, but the objects of reason are the best of knowable objects); and secondly, it is the most continuous, since we can contemplate truth more continuously than we can do anything.