The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has proposed increased restrictions and lower application rates for atrazine. Corn growers need to have options for weed control, and increased scrutiny of atrazine may limit effective herbicides that inhibit the photosystem II within weeds. One alternative weed control option is the premixture of amicarbazone and metribuzin. The atrazine label prohibits planting soybean until the following year, limiting producers to replanting corn or grain sorghum after a failed stand. Amicarbazone allows a 4-mo soybean rotation interval, potentially enabling planting of the crop the same season as failed corn. Therefore, research was conducted in 2023 and 2024 in Fayetteville, Arkansas, to evaluate soybean tolerance to an amicarbazone and metribuzin premixture after a simulated failed corn stand. Amicarbazone was applied at 245, 490, and 735 g ai ha−1 alone and in combination with metribuzin at 140, 280, and 420 g ai ha−1. Soybean was planted following at least 1.3 cm of rain (19 to 20 d after application). The label allows amicarbazone and metribuzin to be applied to corn at 336 and 190 g ha−1, respectively, on silt loam soil with organic matter of 1.5% to 2%. The combination of amicarbazone and metribuzin at 735 and 420 g ha−1, respectively, more than twice the labeled rate for corn, induced 61% to 91% soybean injury 14 d after emergence (DAE). When amicarbazone and metribuzin rates were reduced to 245 and 140 g ha−1, respectively, the injury was 4% in both years at 14 DAE. Yield reductions were observed only after treatments with amicarbazone at 735 g ha−1 applied alone or in combination with metribuzin at 420 g ha−1. Overall, crop response and yield reductions should be expected with an amicarbazone and metribuzin premixture at the highest rates used in this study. However, the label for the premixture will not allow these rates to be applied.