To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Tophets are Phoenician and Punic sanctuaries where cremated infants and children were buried. Many studies focus on the potentially sacrificial nature of these sites, but this article takes a different approach. Combining osteological analysis with a consideration of the archaeological and wider cultural context, the authors explore the short life-courses and mortuary treatments of 12 individuals in the tophet at the Neo-Punic site of Zita, Tunisia. While osteological evidence suggests life at Zita was hard, and systemic health problems may have contributed to the deaths of these individuals, their mortuary rites were attended to with care and without concrete indication of sacrifice.
Contemporary armed conflicts have increasingly been accompanied by belligerents’ calls for civilians to support their military efforts. This article investigates the legal consequences of civilians taking up arms provided by or with the tacit support of the State. It first looks at the implications of civilian involvement from the perspective of a State's international humanitarian law (IHL) and international human rights law obligations, focusing on removing civilians from the vicinity of hostilities, informing and training civilians on the implications of directly participating in hostilities, and respecting and ensuring respect for the law. It then demonstrates that the broader fabric of public international law is tested when civilians are encouraged to engage in hostilities, through a close analysis of the challenge of attributing civilian acts to the State. The article closes with practical recommendations for States to ensure that they uphold their humanitarian and human rights obligations, and to render the law of international responsibility effective when civilians commit systemic violations of IHL.
We sought to review the evidence available to answer the question: Which psychological therapies are effective in the treatment of depression in older adults in an inpatient setting?
Methods
An advanced literature search and systematic review was conducted using Web of Science and PubMed. A set of keywords were identified around depression, older age and the inpatient setting. These were combined with a wide range of keywords around psychological therapies.
Non-English language articles were translated using Google translate.
Articles were reviewed for the relevance to the study question by reviewing the title and abstract. Full text articles were retrieved for those felt to be relevant to the study question.
Results
Of 709 articles identified from both databases, 20 articles were retrieved for full text review. Five studies were identified that appeared to offer insight into the study question. These papers focused on interpersonal therapy, cognitive behavioural therapy, or behavioural group therapy.
Brand and Clingempeel (1992) investigated the incremental implementation of group behavioural therapy in a randomized control trial. The study did not show statistically significant differences between treatment groups, but clinical significance differences supported this intervention's efficacy.
A case study by Soller (1997) followed the journey of a 69-year-old man through inpatient CBT sessions over three and a half months. This was followed with outpatient follow up. There was improvement but this was primarily subjective reporting.
A randomized controlled trial by Snarski et al. (2011) looked at the efficacy of behavioural therapy. The authors' overall conclusion was that patients benefit from this intervention and that further investigations should be done to strengthen their findings further.
A pilot study by Cabanel et al. (2017) focused on determining the feasibility of a multi-professional adaptation of group behavioural therapy sessions. This paper provides a signal towards the effectiveness of multi-professional approach to treatment.
Bollmann et al. (2020) focused on the implementation of interpersonal skills groups. It showed good feasibility as well as good patient adherence. Self-reported and observer-reported depression ratings saw improvement throughout the study.
Conclusion
Although the studies showed a signal towards improvement for a range of therapies, the evidence from these studies is not convincing.
There is a lack of high quality research in this area. More studies are needed to determine the most appropriate psychological therapy to use and how this might be adapted to the transient nature of the inpatient setting.
An evaluation of the service and care provided to eating disordered patients referred to Tier 3 CAMHS within NHS Lanarkshire. Eating disorders are recognised as a relatively common disease with preventable mortality. The primary aim was to determine if patients with eating disorders adhere to the assessment and management as outlined in MEED and SIGN 164. The secondary aim was to scope the number of eating disordered cases to plan recruitment and training of specialist staff.
Methods
The pilot study was carried out in November 2022 and repeated in January 2024. The Electronic Patient Record and paper notes of eating disordered cases assessed in 2023 were used to audit against MEED and SIGN 164. Additional patient demographics including patient's age, sex, median BMI at initial appointment, working diagnosis and suspected co-morbidity were also collected. The service was further evaluated on its processes from source of referral, time taken to be seen, therapies offered and duration within service.
Results
A total of 46 cases were identified in the audit compared to 57 in the pilot study. Most of the cases seen in 2023 were girls in their early teens (89% between the ages 13–16). 10% have a median % BMI <80%. 15 were given a diagnosis of AN (33%), 4 with BN (9%), 4 with ARFID (9%), 2 with OSFED (4%) and 19 with no formal diagnosis (42%). There was a high level of suspected comorbidity (80%).
Referrals were mostly made by GPs (87%), followed by school (11%) and other professionals (2%). The average time taken for the initial assessment was 63 days (40% were seen within 4 weeks). 14 (30%) of cases were offered FBT only whereas 3 (7%) had CBT-E. 7 (15%) did not receive any intervention and 19 (41%) were given other therapies.
With respect to the MEED risk markers, there had been improved recording of weight changes (40% to 80%), hydration status (40% to 70%), temperature (5% to 30%), bloods, over exercising (85% to 90%), purging (75% to 85%) and self-harm behaviours (85% to 90%). However there had been reduction in the recording of BP/HR (80% to 50%), ECG (75% to 40%) and engagement with services (75% to 60%).
Conclusion
Overall, there's some improvement in assessment and management of ED cases but the standard remains inadequate. This project has helped understand the gaps in services and provisions available. Ongoing evaluation is required to help steer service development and optimise patient care.
Induction training is a crucial part of starting work in a new organization as it orientates new staff to their work role and environment, which ensures that they can work safely and competently. Given the wide geographical area of North Wales, there is logistic difficulty to continue with face-to-face induction sessions for new junior doctors. A digital format for regional induction for new doctors from all sites was introduced in 2021. This virtual induction has dealt with the accessibility problem effectively. Nevertheless, there seemed to be some ongoing issues regarding organising the session with speakers due to overlapping clinical duties. Therefore, a quality improvement project has been initiated to improve the delivery of the sessions with minimal disruption to clinical duties. This paper is aimed to share the preliminary experience of the process of digitalisation of the induction programme.
Methods
The pilot regional induction with the above changes was carried out on August 4, 2023 via Microsoft Team Meetings and was accessible to new starters from all three sites in North Wales. The sessions consisted of talks from consultants, the lead clinical pharmacist, the ST in psychiatry and clinical services/Rota coordinator. The induction was divided into morning and afternoon sessions. The participants consisted CTs in psychiatry, GPSTs, and FY trainees. The session was recorded and a pre-recorded session on history taking was introduced. Any queries about pre-recorded session were answered by the chair of session.
Results
It was found that an estimated time saved per induction was 285 minutes with an overall saving for 3 inductions per year of 14.25 hours. The estimated cost saved (based on the lowest pay scale in NHS, £) was £151.13 with an overall saving for 3 inductions per year of £453.39. There were two Assessments of Teaching (AoT) and two Direct Observations of Non-Clinical Skills (DONCS) signed.
Conclusion
Digitalising the regional induction helps to save both time and cost for the health board. It also reduces the risk of speakers in availability. Furthermore, the recording can be sent out early to all the JDs before they join MHLD, which can facilitate a quicker orientation into the new role. It is also a good opportunity for core and specialty trainees to achieve competencies for leadership and teaching.
Flow is a transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) treatment for depression without major side effects that patients use at home. Over 30 years of research/clinical use show tDCS is safe (Razza et al., 2020). Flow is CE-marked for treating depression in Europe. Recent NICE briefing published (NICE, 2023). The patient self-administers and remains awake (NICE, 2015), treatment sessions last for about 30 minutes, and are repeated 5 times weekly for three weeks (Flow, 2023). After the initial three-week period, patients self-administer 3 sessions per week for 3 weeks, and then as long as required (Flow, 2023). Meta-analyses of randomised sham-controlled trials (RCT) show tDCS is associated with significant improvements in depressive symptoms and high rates of clinical response and remission relative to placebo sham stimulation (Mutz et al., 2018, 2019; Moffa et al., 2020; Razza et al., 2020). Flow RCT study depression remission rates are 45% (Fu et al., In Press). Flow incorporates an evidence backed healthy lifestyle behaviour training software app, and depression symptom tracking that enables users to monitor their progress/symptoms. Training modules on: ‘Behaviour activation’, ‘Mindfulness’, ‘Exercise for your brain’, ‘An anti-depression diet’, and ‘Therapeutic sleep’. Flow also provides an integrated platform for clinicians to monitor use and depression symptoms.
In a first for the NHS, in a post-marketing informed consent study, NHFT's community mental health team (CMHT) offered Flow to their patients with a diagnosis of depression and evaluated the feasibility and impact.
Methods
Outcome measure data collection from baseline to 6 week follow-up point. Self-report measures used were depression: Personal Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) and Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS); health related quality of life: EQ-5D-5L; and functioning: Work and Social Adjustment Scale (WSAS). In-depth interviews were undertaken with 14 patients.
Results
There has been high level of adherence (70%) to treatment protocol. There has been statistically significant and ‘reliable improvement’ in depression symptoms. There was statistically significant improvements in real world meaningful functioning and quality of life. Most participants described a positive impact on depressive symptoms, sleep, and functioning.
Conclusion
Flow has been successfully integrated into CMHT treatment offer. It is important to offer CMHT patients an evidence-backed alternative to existing depression treatments (antiddepressant medication and talking therapies). Findings provide support for the approach of delivering together both tDCS and evidence-backed wellbeing behaviour therapy training to patients of CMHTs with experience of depression.
In the densely populated Korail slum of Bangladesh, there is a critical gap in mental health care provision and utilization that was revealed in our ethnographic study. We observed the pivotal role of Community Health Workers (CHWs), Medicine Sellers, and Traditional and Faith-Based Healers (TFHs) in the existing health care service delivery. Moreover, we explored the opportunity to collaborate with them to ensure universal access to biomedical care for serious mental disorders in this slum. As a part of this collaborative approach, we aimed to train these 4 key stakeholders through co-designed training programs that were codeveloped through extensive community engagement including 5 co-designing workshops and 2 writing workshops with them. Furthermore, we refined the initial training program by an expert committee and stakeholders. This training program was piloted to find out the acceptability, feasibility, impact, challenges and areas of improvement.
Methods
We followed mixed-methods approach to evaluate the 3-day pilot training with 20 participants at Mirpur, Dhaka. In quantitative part of evaluation we used a) pre and post test assessment that has been carefully designed to assess knowledge, skills, communication, attitudes and motivation, b) session specific questionnaire to find out feedback of the content, activities and time sensitivity of the session, anonymous feedback forms.
In the qualitative part, we conducted a) focus group discussions (FGDs) after completion of training with each group, b) observational notes from each session for deeper understanding.
Results
The pilot training engaged a diverse group of 20 participants and their age ranged from 24 to 52 years, representing 11 different organizations. Though most of the participants were working in the health sector for a long time, we found more than 10% of the participants believed there was no effective biomedical care for the serious mental disorder during pretesting. However, their perception changed during the training. The role playing and case scenario was the most engaging and enjoyable part. We found the participants considered their knowledge regarding the mental health increased up to 80% from their baseline. Our research team also found the increased number of referrals to the biomedical care from the community after the pilot training.
Conclusion
The increased motivation and sense of responsibility reported by participants underscore the training program's effectiveness and the experience and learning from this pilot helped us to further refinements of the training program for the traditional and faith based healer, community health workers and medicine to transform the mental health scenario in Bangladesh.
Neuropsychiatry is a new and burgeoning field of medicine that combines neuroscientific principles with neurology and psychiatric medicine. Currently, there is little to none medical school literature and/or teaching in the subject. Re-integration of Neurology and Psychiatry disciplines has been recommended, especially in undergraduate and graduate medical training as well as in research. Neuropsychiatry disorders are considered one of the most important causes of disability by the World Health Organization. As a concept, Neuropsychiatry is still not clear on a global scale, from neurological examination to medical school teaching. There have already been active efforts to design and implement Neuropsychiatry training to post-graduate trainees worldwide, particularly in USA, Australia and UK. However, there seems to be no such endeavours towards teaching medical students the role of the brain in the manifestation of neurological as well as psychiatry symptoms. We set out to complete a targeted literature review looking for Neuropsychiatry teaching, if any, in medical schools worldwide.
Methods
A systematic literature search of relevant key phrases was carried out in PubMed and Google Scholar databases. These phrases were searched between 29–31 January 2024 aimed to encompass the full scope of available teaching resources and materials across psychiatry and neurosciences worldwide. These searches included:
(((Neuropsychiatry) AND (Medical students)) AND (Medical school)) AND (Medical education)
(((Neuropsychiatry education) AND (training)) AND (medical students)) AND (Medical education)
(Neuroscience-in-psychiatry) AND (medical school)
((Neuropsychiatry) AND (Medical education)) AND (Medical students)
Further reading was completed from the selected articles (six in total).
Results
A total of 324 results were found from systematic literature search after leaving out the duplicates, of which only 6 articles were included as relevant to aim of our study. None of the articles described clear Neuropsychiatry teaching to the medical students.
Conclusion
Our review highlighted a distinct lack of Neuropsychiatry learning outcomes within medical school curriculum. Neuroscientific principles and methodologies are incorporated in treatment of patients, rationalising clear differentiation between neurology or psychiatry, but the overall picture from both disciplines and utilisation towards diagnosing and managing the cluster of symptoms manifesting from aberrant brain processes is still unclear. In line with previous research around education measurement, we propose that fundamentals from both Neurology and Psychiatry need to be introduced as clinical neuroscience early in medical school and this can be further continued.
Neurodivergent women have different experiences during pregnancy, childbirth, and parenthood than neurotypical women. However, little is known about the perinatal mental health outcomes and parenting experiences in women with Neurodevelopmental Disorders (ND). The systematic review aimed to summarise the literature on perinatal mental health outcomes and parenting experiences among women with ND.
Methods
MEDLINE, Embase and PsycINFO databases were searched in October 2023 using the keywords related to pregnancy outcomes, perinatal period, mental health, neurodivergent, and neurodevelopmental disorders. Papers were also identified through citation and/or hand searching. Title, abstracts, and full-text articles were independently screened by two authors, and data were extracted using a custom data extraction spreadsheet. The Joanna Briggs Institute and the Mixed Methods appraisal tools were used for the critical appraisal. The heterogeneity across the included studies ruled out the use of meta-analysis. Therefore, results were summarised using a narrative synthesis.
Results
Fourteen studies were included in the final review; four cohort, four case-control, three cross-sectional and three qualitative studies across 940,354 participants. The studies investigated women with Autism, Asperger's syndrome and Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), who were either clinically diagnosed or scored appropriately on diagnostic questionnaires. Perinatal mental health outcomes covered anxiety and depression. These were measured using questionnaires such as the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale, participant interviews and clinical diagnosis from qualified healthcare professionals. All fourteen studies found a correlation between Neurodevelopmental Disorders and perinatal anxiety and/or depression symptoms. Seven studies found that neurodivergent women had adverse pregnancy and early parenting experiences. Results suggested this correlation may be mediated by factors such as unsatisfactory healthcare, lack of maternal-infant bond, increased sensory overload, issues with emotional attachment, difficulty reading the facial expression of the baby and problems with breastfeeding. Overall, women with ND were more likely to feel anxious and overwhelmed during the perinatal period, a potential risk factor for perinatal mental illness.
Conclusion
Women with ND are at a higher risk of developing perinatal mental illness and adverse early parenting experiences. Abnormal physical and sensory challenges during pregnancy as well as difficulty with emotional connection and infant bonding during postpartum all contribute to the increased risk of perinatal mental illness. Adaptations to appointments and specialised perinatal care are required for women with ND yet are often not provided. To reduce the risk of perinatal mental illness in women with ND, improvements must be made to the delivery of perinatal care and the knowledge of those providing the care.
Integral to Bleuler's concept of schizophrenia, anomalous beliefs regarding the self are crucial to maladaptive social functioning. In schizophrenia, a predisposition to unusual bodily experiences, coupled with reduced awareness and increased social isolation, leads to hallucinations and delusions. Proprioceptive hallucinations, a subset of bodily hallucinations, present a challenging diagnosis due to their subjective nature, often resembling genuine bodily perceptions. We present the case of a 42-year-old man with untreated psychotic illness, manifesting perceptual abnormalities in the modality of proprioception.
Methods
Mr. X was referred to Early Intervention in Psychosis (EIP), believing that all his joints were dislocated despite a normal neurological examination, Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), and blood tests. Pertinently, childhood adversities and a seven-year history of prodromal and schizophrenia symptoms, chronic marijuana usage, potentially triggered by separating from his ex-partner, were present. At assessment, Mr. X recalled a delusional memory from age 5, seemingly heralding the onset of his illness. He displayed thought disorder, poor sleep and lacked insight. Olanzapine titrated to 15mg omni nocte (ON) improved sleep, but insight remained poor.
Results
This case of rare proprioceptive hallucinations presenting in middle-age underscores the impact of positive schizophrenia symptoms on social impairment, suggesting a link between unusual bodily experiences and social isolation. Proprioception, encompassing joint perceptions, muscle force, and effort, contributes to body image by combining with exteroception. Interactions with others, influenced by our bodily sense, are crucial for adaptive social functioning. The social deafferentation hypothesis posits that loneliness in schizophrenia may heighten susceptibility to bodily aberrations. The psychological formulation and the chronic use of marijuana on Mr. X's psychopathology, although not thoroughly explored, cannot be overstated.
Conclusion
Proprioception, vital for body image and social interactions, contributes to maladaptive functioning. The potent link between positive schizophrenia symptoms and social impairment needs exploring.
There has been criticism surrounding the lack of clarity regarding treatments offered within forensic inpatient units for people with learning disability and co-existing mental health problems. The Ten-Point Treatment Programme is a framework for treatments within such settings. It incorporates the four stages of assessment and motivational work, foundation and offence-specific treatments, consolidation and relapse prevention and finally discharge management. Although evidence based and evaluated in outcome studies, explaining its content to those with learning disability can be problematic. Communication difficulties affect the way information is comprehended and interpreted from both a linguistic and pragmatic perspective in this group. The provision of Easy Read information can address this difficulty.
Our aim was to co-produce, with experts by experience, an easy read version of the Ten Point Treatment Programme; and to evaluate this resource.
Methods
This was a quality improvement project within an in-patient medium secure unit in England. The co-production of the easy read version was led by two speech and language therapists, two psychiatrists, one Education Manager and two experts by experience. The latter advised on content, wording, format and font. Content was adapted in line with standard easy read requirements and guidelines. Following a focus group meetings, a provisional easy read version was approved and introduced in the service. This service innovation was evaluated through semi-structured interviews with six experts by experience and ten multidisciplinary team members who had used the resource. Responses were transcribed and subjected to thematic analysis.
Results
The three main themes covered in the evaluation responses related to accessibility, appearance and usefulness. The sub-themes under accessibility were the simplicity of vocabulary and short sentence length. Regarding appearance, the key sub-themes were about the effective use of colour, the inclusion of relevant and meaningful images, and the balance between words and pictures. On usefulness, the main sub-theme was about understanding the treatment pathway better and hence feeling motivated to engage. This was reflected by the staff group as well. There were some comments on accessibility that were less positive, including service user indications that the number and complexity of words were still high.
Conclusion
The co-produced easy read version of the Ten-point treatment programme has been received positively by service users and staff. For both groups, it brings clarity about the treatment pathway and its stages. It is incorporated into the admission pack for new admissions and features in new staff induction programmes.
The primary aim was to establish the preferences of the majority of core trainees regarding online, in-person, or hybrid teaching in order to assess if the online format created during the COVID 19 Pandemic should be maintained.
Secondary aims were:
• To collect feedback regarding the barriers to in-person teaching.
• To collect feedback regarding the course content.
• To alter the way the course is presented (if required) and to incorporate the feedback regarding the course content into the course.
• To re-audit to see if the intervention was successful.
Methods
• Surveymonkey was used to generate an online survey with 5 questions.
• There were a mix of quantitative and qualitative questions.
• Responses were collected between 26th September 2022 and 10th October 2022 and results were presented at the Tutors Committee Meeting and Junior Doctors Forum.
• Changes were implemented in the curriculum:
1. Introduced specific neuroscience teaching.
2. Small exam specific study groups were encouraged.
3. It was decided that teaching would remain hybrid as per the majority preference and to allow equal access to teaching for all trainees (as per the GMC guidance).
A second survey with the same questions was sent out and responses collected between 19th November 2023 to 29th November 2023 to establish whether opinions had changed and to see if the intervention was successful.
• The most common barriers to in-person teaching were the difficulty in finding parking (70%, n = 14), and being unable to leave work on time due to clinical responsibilities (50%, n = 10).
• The most common preferred frequency of in-person attendance for the hybrid model was monthly (45%, n = 9).
• Topics requested to be covered (free-form question) included psychopharmacology, CAMHS, perinatal, geriatric, neuroanatomy and neuroscience.
Nov 2023
• There were 22 responses overall, including new trainees that had not done the survey last year.
• The most common barriers were the same: difficulty finding parking (64%, n = 14) and clinical responsibilities (55%, n = 12).
• It was commented that neuroscience related teaching had improved.
Conclusion
There was a clear preference in both surveys amongst trainees for either online or hybrid teaching formats. Hence a decision was made to continue the current format of flexible teaching.
This project aimed to create and deliver a simulation-based course to improve trainees’ knowledge, practical skills and confidence as well as leadership and multidisciplinary-team working. We evaluated the effectiveness of this training and simulation as a learning experience. Simulation in psychiatry is a relatively new field compared with other specialities. Literature shows that experiential learning in psychiatry is effective for developing clinical and communication skills for doctors, and confidence in leadership. It is vital we work towards the National Health Service Long Term Plan for improving mental health care for those with serious mental illness which includes better training for doctors. This course was designed to enhance the ELFT training programme focusing on applications of theoretical knowledge.
Methods
A simulation-based course was delivered to core trainees and general practitioner trainees at induction to psychiatry. This was based on the Royal College of Psychiatrists curriculum and input from our People Participation team to ensure authenticity of scenarios. We surveyed trainees to inform the development of our pilot in February 2022 and subsequently developed two half-day courses facilitated in August 2022 following feedback. The scenarios we created were: risk assessment, section 5(2) Mental Health Act (MHA) assessment, managing agitation and violence, escalating concerns to a senior, section 136 MHA assessment, seclusion review, discussion with medical registrar for physical health concerns, collateral history and information-giving in child psychiatry. We used a structured debrief model (what went well, what could you have done differently, what was the ‘golden moment'?) and provided relevant teaching. Service users joined the debrief to share their perspectives and lived experiences. We collected and analysed quantitative and qualitative feedback.
Results
Ten trainees attended the pilot course, followed by eleven on day 1 and nine on day 2 in August 2022. Results from questionnaires revealed post-course, 100% of participants felt more confident in their psychiatric skills and found this experience to be valuable for clinical practice. 100% would recommend this simulation to others. Qualitative data showed participants thought scenarios were realistic, the environment was supportive and feedback was comprehensive. They also appreciated the service user involvement.
Conclusion
Trainees reported simulation provided a safe and engaging environment to learn practical skills which better prepared them for work. This course is now embedded into the ELFT induction programme and enables doctors to develop their confidence and have a better understanding of service user perspectives. Future development of this course will involve allied health professionals.
In 2023, Claudia Goldin received the Nobel Prize for her groundbreaking research in economics. In this article, I use Goldin’s research to reflect on the role of history of education in academic research. I argue that Goldin’s remarkable achievement underscores the need for historians of education to reach a wider disciplinary audience in the humanities and social sciences. Goldin’s success lies not in isolating her focus to a subfield, but in connecting historical research to wider concerns in the discipline of economics. Goldin’s research thus reminds us of the skills required of historians of education: to understand the research interest and terminology of other research fields, and to use historical methods to address the key problems that those research fields explore. That is, we need to learn how to apply historical methods to what are essentially nonhistorical problems.
To implement a digital handover system within Oxleas inpatient sites to improve the visibility of tasks both completed and pending, to reduce the number of tasks missed and to provide a clear audit trail relating to tasks handed over.
Methods
Junior doctors providing on-call cover to acute sites across all 3 boroughs served by Oxleas were invited to complete a questionnaire relating to the efficacy of handover. With this data & information gathered through discussions with the trust's informatics team, a digital handover system, based in Microsoft Teams, was developed. This was piloted and refined through 6 PDSA cycles from September 2022 – August 2023 before being implemented across all Oxleas acute sites from August 2023. Further questionnaires were completed 1 month & 6 months after its roll out to assess the impact of the change.
Results
Doctors were asked to complete a questionnaire at 3 time points: pre-intervention (T0, 20 respondents), 1-month post-intervention (T1, 13 respondents), and 6-months post-intervention (T2, 12 respondents).
• At T0, 92.3% of respondents reported tasks created by the on-call team had been missed due to staff not being aware, this reduced to 11.1% at T1, and 28.6% at T2.
• At T0, 23.1% of respondents agree/strongly agree that it is easy to view tasks that have been done on their ward out-of-hours.
• By comparison, at T1 69.2% reported the digital handover system has made it easier to view what had been done on a ward out-of-hours, rising to 83.3% at T2.
• At T1, 76.9% reported the digital handover system has made it easier to view tasks when on-call, rising to 83.3% at T2.
• At T0, 30% agree/strongly agree that the outgoing on-call doctor leaves a written record of tasks completed and outstanding. This rose to 69.3% at T1, and 41.7% at T2.
Conclusion
There is strong evidence that effective handover is a key aspect of clinical care, and failure of this is a preventable cause of patient harm. The initial questionnaire highlighted issues with the efficacy and safety of the handover process within acute sites at Oxleas, which the digital system sought to address. After implementation of the digital system, the findings demonstrated improvements in the handover process, with visibility increasing for tasks both completed & in progress, and fewer reports of tasks being missed by the ward-based doctors, which was maintained over the 6-month follow up period.
A large body of evidence suggests that experiences of, and access to mental healthcare in England varies according to ethnicity. Inequitable use of restrictive interventions is of particular concern, including within perinatal services: a national-level study of inpatients on Mother and Baby Units (MBU) in 2017 found that 28% of white patients were detained under the mental health act (MHA), compared with 61.5% of Black African, and 66 – 77% of Asian mothers. We carried out an audit with the aim of examining detention rates, length of stay, and time to first section 17 leave on an MBU in South Manchester according to ethnicity and English language ability, to compare with national averages.
Methods
We identified all patients discharged from Andersen Ward (an MBU) between March 2022 and March 2023. Using electronic medical records we extracted information on: ethnicity, language spoken (English vs other), mental health act status (detained under Section 2/3 vs informal), duration of admission, date of detention, date of first Section 17 leave. We calculated the percentage of patients who were detained according to ethnicity (White British, Mixed/other, Asian, Black), and the odds of detention according to ethnicity. Statistical significance was assessed using chi-squared testing. We also compared average length of stay and time to first section 17 leave by ethnicity.
Results
74 patients had been discharged from the MBU within the audit period. 88% of Black inpatients were admitted under the Mental Health act, compared with 72.7% of Asian mothers, 33.3% of Mixed ethnicity or other ethnicities and 28.3% of white mothers. Differences in detention rates according to ethnicity were statistically significant. Of 11 mothers documented as having a language other than English as their primary language, all had been detained. Length of admission and days to first section 17 leave were not significantly different between ethnicities.
Conclusion
Many factors may contribute to the observed higher detention rates among non-White patients: language barriers and a lack of intercultural competence could lead to risk-averse decision-making during MHA assessments, and different help-seeking patterns might mean White mothers seek help earlier, or for less severe mental health problems. Recommendations include expanding access to high-quality interpreters; investigating factors underlying MHA decision-making through qualitative research; and improving cultural competence among section 12 approved clinicians by incorporating feedback from ethnic minority patients into training and refresher courses.
Missing data is a challenge that most researchers encounter. It is a concern that continues to be analyzed and addressed for solutions. Missing data occurs when there is no data stored for certain variables relating to participants. In health surveys, when participants answer in the form of “I don't know” or “I'd prefer not to answer”, these responses can, in many cases, be categorized as missing data responses from a participant in a specific category or question.
The eight-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-8) is an essential tool in healthcare and clinical settings to assess an individual's mental health, specifically related to symptoms of depression. The items are scored on a scale from 0 to 3 with the total score obtained by summing the scores for each item. Higher PHQ-8 scores indicate the presence of depressive symptoms.
We used empirical data from a previous study on depression symptoms in patients with coronary heart disease to study the effect of considering the answers “I do not know” and “I prefer not to answer” as missing values when estimating the percentage of depression using PHQ-8. Moreover, we studied the effect of the complete case analysis and multiple imputation on parameter estimates and confidence intervals. The outcome of this study aims to shed light on the development of missing data procedural knowledge and provide methodological support for public health decision-making when data with missing values are collected.
Furthermore, this study aims to prevent the exclusion of missing data rather than to generate data.
Methods
A simulation study with 1000 replicates was performed. Four common statistical machine learning methods for handling missing values were included in this study. These are K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN), K-Means, Classification and Regression Trees (CART), and Random Forest (RF) imputations. Five clusters were used for KNN and K-mean. Likewise, five multiple imputations were used for the CART and RF methods. The simulation was based on publicly available data with available PHQ-8 data for 1096 subjects. In the simulation study and for each replication, multivariate missing values were generated using the missing-at-random (MAR) assumption with 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, and 50% proportions of missingness. The percent of depression was calculated using the PHQ-8 questionnaire and a comparison was made between estimated actual depression, complete-case analysis, KNN, Kmean, RF, and CART, respectively.
Results
The Median age of the subjects was 69 (interquartile range: 61–67) and more males (72.9%) than females were included in the data. The estimated actual depression was 16.8, whereas the estimated percentage of depression varies between 6.9–13.5, 16.2–16.7, 16.3–16.7, 16.6–16.7 and 16.7–16.8 for the complete case, KNN, Kmean, RF and CART respectively.
Conclusion
The results of this simulation study show that missing PHQ-8 data are best handled by applying multiple imputations based on CART or RF. However, using K-Means or KNN leads to a good estimate of the true percentage of depression. Furthermore, the results of this simulation study show that complete-case analysis leads to biased estimates of the true percentage of depression. Nevertheless, further investigation is needed to address the problem of missing PHQ-8 data under the assumption of missing not at random.
This review delves into the understanding of depression within African communities, extending its scope to nations with significant African populations, aiming to enhance service provision for these patients. While focusing on cultural experiences of depression that transcend geographical boundaries, it builds upon existing literature predominantly centred on sub-Saharan African countries.
Methods
A comprehensive literature search was conducted across multiple databases, yielding 13 relevant articles after applying stringent criteria. Following Cochrane guidelines, search terms encompassed population (Africa, Africans, African communities), exposure (Depression, Depressive disorder, Dysphoria, Dysthymia, Low mood), and outcomes (Cultural expressions, Cultural variations, Somatization, Cultural framework, Cross-cultural research, Service provision).
Results
Analysing selected articles through the CASP checklist, a narrative synthesis of qualitative studies over the past twelve years elucidated diverse perceptions and expressions of depression in African communities compared with Western contexts. Three major themes emerged: Expressions of depression (with subthemes: Attitudes towards depression), Perceptions of depression (including Stigmatization), and culturally acceptable forms of treatment (including Barriers towards treatment).
Conclusion
The review underscores the significance of integrating culturally acceptable treatment methods into psychological therapy for improved healthcare delivery. Collaboration between clinicians and patients is pivotal, with religious assistance emerging as a culturally acceptable treatment avenue. Establishing therapeutic alliances with religious communities could enhance treatment effectiveness. Further research is warranted to explore the impact of religious activity on depression symptoms and progression, as well as the influence of mental health providers' religious backgrounds on treatment dynamics. This holistic approach is crucial for addressing the unique cultural nuances surrounding depression in African communities and optimizing patient care.
Limited data suggest that negative mood symptoms in the menopause transition may be associated with a higher prevalence of alcohol misuse and other risk-taking behaviours in menopausal women. Excessive alcohol consumption can exacerbate menopausal symptoms, reduce quality of life and is associated with chronic morbidity that overlaps with the consequences of long-term oestrogen deficiency (such as osteoporosis and cardiovascular disease). The aim of this survey was to explore the impact of mental ill-health on alcohol consumption and gambling habits in menopausal women.
Methods
We constructed an anonymous survey consisting of multiple-choice and free-text questions. The survey was distributed online via social media channels on the 22 August 2023 and was open for 6 weeks. All perimenopausal and menopausal women were invited to participate. Responses were collected using the Qualtrics survey platform and analysed in Excel for descriptive statistics.
Results
1,178 responses were submitted. One in three women reported drinking more alcohol during the perimenopause/menopause; 15% of women drink more than the recommended maximum of 14 units per week, and 24% (286) are spending up to £50 per week on alcohol. 70% (332) cited anxiety, stress, and/or depression as the reason for their increased alcohol consumption, whilst 29% (135) said they drank to alleviate menopause symptoms. Further, 5% (54) of respondents admitted gambling more since the onset of perimenopause/menopause; 43% (27) said it was due to anxiety, stress, and/or depression, whilst 13% (9) said they do so to help manage their menopause symptoms.
Conclusion
This anonymous, cross-sectional survey found evidence of an association between menopause and addiction. Increased awareness of this association should facilitate earlier recognition and more timely access to support and effective treatment for addiction, including hormone replacement therapy to treat menopausal symptoms that may underlie and/or exacerbate unhealthy lifestyle behaviours.