To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Executive function (EF) deficits are consistently linked to psychopathology symptoms, though the mechanisms linking poor EF to symptom expression remain unclear.
Methods
The study used the Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) approach to examine relationships between teacher-reported latent psychopathology symptoms, including a general psychopathology factor (P-Factor), and EF in young children with emerging mental health problems. Participants were 804 children (70.8% male; aged 49–89 months) referred by their teachers for cognitive, emotional, or behavioral problems at school. To assess psychopathology, teachers completed the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ). EF measures included inhibition, cognitive flexibility, working memory, sustained attention, and episodic memory, assessed using the NIH Toolbox, Automated Working Memory Assessment, and the Amsterdam Neuropsychological Test battery.
Results
Structural equation modeling (incorporating confirmatory factor analysis) showed reasonable model fit and supported a P-Factor structure. Correlational analyses explored EF–psychopathology associations, followed by a sensitivity analysis controlling for sex. We observed patterns of cognitive processes that showed inverse associations between EF performance and specific clinical problems. Sustained attention was positively associated with emotional problems but negatively associated with hyperactivity problems. Sex-stratified analyses revealed distinct patterns, with inhibition problems strongly linked to conduct and hyperactivity problems, but in females only.
Conclusions
The findings support poor EF as a transdiagnostic risk factor associated with incremental vulnerability for childhood psychopathology. Divergent findings for sustained attentional processes suggest they can be adaptive in some contexts but maladaptive in others. Screening for EF difficulties in children could enhance early identification and inform interventions.
A long-term physical health condition (LTC) is one ‘that cannot currently be cured but can be controlled with medication and/or other therapies’. Around 30% of people with an LTC have mental health co-morbidities. Systematic reviews suggest adapted cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) produces positive outcomes for LTC clients compared with control conditions. However, limited research includes long-term follow-ups or the client’s voice, preventing conclusions about mechanisms of change or sustainability. This qualitative study explored long-term health experiences of CBT for adults with LTCs in UK primary care, and what elements of CBT participants deemed responsible for change. The sample included 10 individuals with an LTC. Findings were constructed through inductive-deductive reflexive thematic analysis, integrating participant-led narratives with psychological theory. Four themes were identified: a validating and normalising therapeutic relationship, lack of therapist skill and knowledge of LTCs, adjusting to and accepting LTC, and de-catastrophising LTC-specific beliefs. Participants discussed the importance of both common and specific factors. A trusting therapeutic relationship was essential, while collaboratively applying techniques to promote adjustment and acceptance was necessary for long-term gains. The study highlights embedding health psychology theory and third-wave approaches within a process-based, transdiagnostic framework enhanced through LTC-specific training and supervision. By attending to identity disruption, illness representations, values conflict, and low self-efficacy, therapists can deliver interventions that consider the lived realities of LTCs.
Key learning aims
(1) To explore how participants understood and described the emotional, cognitive, and identity-related changes that occurred following CBT, with particular attention to long-term adjustment and meaning making.
(2) To identify which therapeutic processes participants perceived as most helpful or unhelpful, including both CBT-specific strategies and common relational factors, and how these were thought to influence change.
(3) To contextualise participants’ accounts within broader health psychology and process-based frameworks, considering how their narratives reflect mechanisms highlighted in models such as the Self-Regulatory Model, the Transdiagnostic Model of Adjustment to LTCs, and third-wave approaches.
Formal thought disorder (FTD) is a highly disabling transdiagnostic feature that impedes communication and social ties. Progress in understanding and treating FTD has been hampered by the uncertainties in its assessment.
Aims
We examined if a short 3–5min assessment of transcribed speech can capture the latent dimensions and network structure of FTD and predict functional outcomes.
Method
In a transdiagnostic sample (N = 666) with a single longitudinal follow-up over 3–12 months (n = 244), we administered the short form of the Thought and Language Index to measure eight individual features of FTD. We determined the baseline factor structure of FTD, its temporal invariance at follow-up, and the predictive validity of FTD dimensions on the global single-item Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale scores at baseline and follow-up. We identified the most influential and putative primary phenomena within the FTD syndrome, using network analysis.
Results
Factor analyses revealed a stable three-factor model of FTD: impoverishment (poverty of speech, weakening of goal), loosening (looseness, illogicality) and peculiarities (peculiar words, peculiar sentences), with excellent fit (Comparative Fit Index: 0.997, root mean square error of approximation: 0.040) and metric invariance over time. Impoverishment and peculiarities predicted functioning at baseline and 3–12 months later (cross-sectional: β = –0.196, p < 0.001 and β = –0.298, p = 0.001, respectively; longitudinal: β = –0.201, p = 0.037 and β = –0.336, p = 0.042, respectively). Looseness and poverty of speech were putative primary features influencing other FTD phenomena. Weakening of goal and peculiar sentences were the most connected phenomena.
Conclusions
By integrating latent variable and network approaches, we provide a unified, empirically grounded framework to interpret FTD assessed using a brief speech task. We report a replicable three-dimensional structure, identify central symptoms that may maintain the FTD syndrome, and the specific dimensions that influence functional disability. These findings clarify the prognostically valuable features of FTD for future mechanistic and interventional research.
Social cognitive deficits are common across many psychiatric conditions and contribute to broader social dysfunction. One hypothesized mechanism involves altered basic visual processing, which may disrupt the perception of low-level social cues and, in turn, compromise broader social cognitive processes. Here, we examined relations between basic visual processing and different levels of social cognition in a transdiagnostic youth sample.
Methods
A sample of 148 youth, ranging from healthy individuals to individuals with neuropsychiatric diagnoses and significant social dysfunction, completed two measures of basic visual processing (contrast sensitivity and visual integration) and a battery of social cognition tasks spanning lower-level (gaze perception) to mid-level (emotion recognition) to higher-level (theory of mind) social cognition. We used a four-level path model to test whether basic visual processing predicts gaze perception, which in turn predicts emotion recognition, which predicts theory of mind.
Results
Poorer contrast sensitivity and visual integration were associated with less precise gaze perception, which was, in turn, associated with worse emotion recognition, which was associated with worse theory of mind. This four-level path model demonstrated good fit and showed superior fit compared to alternative models.
Conclusions
These findings suggest that basic visual processing influences the perception of basic social cues (e.g. gaze direction), which subsequently impairs more complex social perception and inference. Notably, this study extends prior observations from individuals with chronic schizophrenia to a transdiagnostic youth sample, indicating that altered basic visual processing may be a shared mechanism contributing to social cognitive deficits across psychiatric disorders and illness stages.
The present study aimed to explore sleep diary-derived parameters and sleep measures as mediators of the effects of the Transdiagnostic Intervention for Sleep and Circadian Dysfunction (TSC) on psychological outcomes. A secondary analysis of a two-arm randomized controlled trial of a group-based TSC for major depressive disorder was conducted. The participants included 152 adults (mean age = 34.0; 79.6% female) who were randomized into either the TSC or care-as-usual group. Mediation analysis indicated that reduction in insomnia symptom severity (standardized indirect effects: −0.06 to −0.17), sleep disturbance (−0.04 to −0.22), and sleep-related impairment (−0.04 to −0.17) was significantly mediated by sleep diary-derived sleep parameters. The treatment effects on depressive symptoms (standardized indirect effects: −0.05 to −0.10), anxiety symptoms (−0.04 to −0.07), fatigue (−0.05 to −0.09), functional impairment (−0.06 to −0.09), and quality of life (0.04 to 0.08) were sequentially mediated by sleep parameters and insomnia symptom severity. However, the severity of insomnia symptoms alone (magnitudes of standardized indirect effects: 0.09–0.17) but not sleep parameters alone (0.00–0.07) mediated the treatment effects on psychological outcomes, indicating that sleep parameters need to influence subjective sleep measures to sequentially affect psychological outcomes. These results underscore the critical roles of subjective sleep measures in clinical improvements within a sleep-targeted intervention.
Language impairments are common in affective and psychotic disorders, yet their patterns and underlying pathomechanisms remain insufficiently understood. A transdiagnostic perspective provides a framework for identifying shared and disorder-specific language alterations across diagnostic boundaries. Combining natural language processing (NLP) with network analysis enables the investigation of complex associations between linguistic, cognitive, and psychopathological features.
Methods
Spontaneous speech from N = 372 participants (119 MDD, 27 BD, 48 SSD and 178 HC) was elicited using four Thematic Apperception Test pictures (~12 min per participant). NLP models were applied to extract latent linguistic variables across various levels, including lexical diversity, syntactic complexity, semantic coherence, and disfluencies. Network analysis was used to relate linguistic variables, psychopathology (SAPS, SANS, HAM-A, HAM-D, YMRS, TLI, GAF), and cognitive performance (attention, verbal memory, recognition, and verbal fluency).
Results
Linguistic variables formed the densest network cluster, with type–token ratio, mean length of utterance, and syntactic complexity emerging as central nodes. Psychopathology variables were less cohesive, while TLI “Impoverishment”, coherence mean, and executive functioning bridged linguistic, cognitive, and psychopathological domains. Network comparison tests revealed no significant differences in linguistic–cognitive network structure across HC, MDD, BD, and SSD.
Conclusions
Linguistic networks show high structural consistency across healthy individuals and patients, whereas psychopathological symptom networks reflect transdiagnostic profiles. These findings support a dimensional and transdiagnostic framework underscore shared language–cognition mechanisms, and highlight executive functioning as key cross-domain connection, which opens up new avenues for dimensional research into the pathophysiological and etiological mechanisms underlying language dysfunctions.
Exercise improves stress perception and sleep quality and reduces repetitive negative thinking in patients with various mental disorders. However, it is unclear whether changes in these processes mediate treatment effects on psychopathology in a transdiagnostic sample.
Methods
Physically inactive adult outpatients with depressive disorders, agoraphobia, panic disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, and/or nonorganic primary insomnia were randomly allocated to ImPuls – a 6-month transdiagnostic group exercise intervention – plus treatment-as-usual (n = 198), or to a treatment-as-usual alone control group (n = 201) at 10 study sites between March 2021 and May 2022. The primary outcome was global symptom severity; perceived stress, repetitive negative thinking, and sleep quality were included as mediators. All variables were assessed at baseline, 6 months, and 12 months using validated rating scales. As a secondary analysis of an RCT, intention-to-treat analyses were performed using structural equation modeling to test whether changes in stress perception, repetitive negative thinking, and sleep quality mediate treatment effects on changes in global symptom severity in two path models (from baseline to 6 and 12 months, respectively).
Results
Treatment effects on global symptom severity were fully mediated by changes in perceived stress (6 months: β = −0.99, p = .024; 12 months: β = −1.28, p = .014) and repetitive negative thinking (6 months: β = −1.34, p = .004; 12 months: β = −0.94, p = .024).
Conclusions
Our results suggest that changes in perceived stress and repetitive negative thinking may be key transdiagnostic mechanisms underlying the treatment effect of exercise on global symptom severity.
Impairments in mentalizing, or theory of mind, occur across psychiatric disorders. Static illustrations are widely used to assess mentalizing due to their simplicity, and they allow assessment of specific cognitive processes. However, systematic comparisons of impairments between psychiatric disorders, neurodevelopmental disorders, and at-risk groups in mentalizing tasks with static illustrations are currently lacking.
Methods
A systematic review with pairwise and network meta-analyses (NMA) was conducted to evaluate mentalizing impairments using tasks with static illustrations across psychiatric disorders compared to healthy controls (HCs) and between groups. Subgroup analyses examined specific mentalizing domains (false belief, humor, and intentionality), and meta-regression analyses explored potential moderators. The ceiling effects of specific tasks were also examined.
Results
Eighty-nine studies were included, involving 9,038 participants and 11 psychiatric conditions. Significant mentalizing deficits were observed across all conditions versus HCs, except for the familial risk for bipolar disorder group. NMA demonstrated that schizophrenia (g = −0.960) and early schizophrenia (g = −0.785) exhibited the most pronounced impairments, followed by borderline personality disorder (g = −0.612) and obsessive-compulsive disorder (g = −0.613). Particularly, schizophrenia showed significantly greater deficits than autism, bipolar disorder, clinical and familial high risk for schizophrenia, and depression. Domain-specific analyses highlighted differential impairment patterns. The presence of prominent ceiling effects suggests major limitations of tasks with static illustrations.
Conclusions
This review provides detailed insights into transdiagnostic and disorder-specific patterns of mentalizing impairments with tasks using static illustrations. Findings highlight the importance of domain-specific approaches, examining interindividual variability, refining assessment tools, and implementing targeted interventions.
High uncertainty in recent global health, geopolitical, and climate crises has been proposed as one important driver of the rise in youth mental health problems. This makes intolerance of uncertainty – a transdiagnostic risk factor for mental health problems – a promising target for intervention.
Methods
This study presents a novel single-session online training that took a synergistic mindset approach to promote uncertainty-as-adaptive and growth mindsets. The novel Uncertainty-Mindset Training was compared with Psychoeducation and No-Training control groups in 259 older adolescents/emerging adults (18-to-24-year-olds).
Results
The Uncertainty-Mindset Training reduced intolerance of uncertainty, anxiety symptoms, and depression symptoms 1 month later. Importantly, the clinical gains were mediated by reductions in intolerance of uncertainty.
Conclusions
Given that this ultra-brief training can be delivered at scale globally and at no cost to the users, it shows promise for significant public health impacts.
How psychotic symptoms, depressive symptoms, cognitive deficits, and functional impairment may interact with one another in schizophrenia or bipolar disorder is unclear.
Methods
This study explored these interactions in a discovery sample of 339 Chinese, of whom 146 had first-episode schizophrenia and 193 had bipolar disorder. Psychotic symptoms were assessed using the Positive and Negative Symptom Scale; depressive symptoms, using the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; cognitive deficits, using tests of processing speed, executive function, and logical memory; and functional impairment, using clinical assessments. Network models connecting the four types of variables were developed and compared between men and women and between disorders. Potential causal relationships among the variables were explored through directed acyclic graphing. The results in the discovery sample were compared to those obtained for a validation sample of 235 Chinese, of whom 138 had chronic schizophrenia and 97 had bipolar disorder.
Results
In the discovery and validation cohorts, schizophrenia and bipolar disorder showed similar networks of associations, in which the central hubs included ‘disorganized’ symptoms, depressive symptoms, and deficits in processing speed during the digital symbol substitution test. Directed acyclic graphing suggested that disorganized symptoms were upstream drivers of cognitive impairment and functional decline, while core depressive symptoms (e.g. low mood) drove somatic and anxiety symptoms.
Conclusions
Our study advocates for transdiagnostic, network-informed strategies prioritizing the mitigation of disorganization and depressive symptoms to disrupt symptom cascades and improve functional outcomes in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.
Given substantial comorbidity among, and considerable heterogeneity within, psychiatric diagnoses, researchers have suggested alternative systems for classifying psychopathology. The Hierarchical Taxonomy of Psychopathology (HiTOP) is a recently proposed framework for understanding mental disorders based on how symptoms and diagnoses tend to cluster across individuals. While the model is grounded in existing research and supported by recent meta-analytic evidence, its structure has not yet been directly tested using large, representative clinical datasets. In this study, we used electronic health record (EHR) data to examine the overall organization of mental disorders as proposed by HiTOP, with the goal of informing future research on biological and environmental risk factors as well as important life outcomes.
Methods
Data were drawn from the All of Us Research Program, a landmark nationwide US biobank initiative designed to advance population-scale health research, and included participants’ psychiatric diagnoses and sociodemographic correlates as documented in their EHRs. A total of 127,963 participants and 39 primary diagnoses were identified. We analyzed patterns of co-occurrence among psychiatric diagnoses to identify broader psychopathology dimensions, assess the overall structure of mental disorders, and clarify the placement of conditions that have been inconsistently categorized in past research. Several competing dimensional models were compared based on their statistical fit and complementary assessments of factor strength, specificity, and reproducibility.
Results
A model identifying six broad and correlated dimensions – Fear, Distress, Externalizing, Substance Use, Thought Problems, and Neurodevelopmental Disorders – provided the best fit to the data. This structure was highly consistent across analyses and showed strong split-half replicability and meaningful associations with relevant clinical and demographic characteristics.
Conclusions
These findings support a 6-factor model of psychopathology that broadly resembles major dimensions in the HiTOP framework. By addressing key gaps in the literature, this study advances our understanding of the structure and correlates of mental disorders. The results offer a foundation for more nuanced investigations into the etiology, progression, and treatment of mental health conditions.
Test whether a dissonance-based transdiagnostic eating disorder treatment, body project treatment (BPT), produces greater reduction in brain reward region response to the thin ideal and behaviors used to pursue this ideal and eating disorder symptoms, and higher abstinence from eating disorder behaviors and remittance from eating disorder diagnoses than a matched transdiagnostic interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT).
Methods
Women with various eating disorders (N = 83) were randomized to 8-week group-implemented BPT or IPT and completed functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) at pretest and posttest, and surveys and masked diagnostic interviews at pretest, posttest, and 6-month follow-up.
Results
BPT versus IPT participants showed significantly greater reductions in mid cingulate cortex response to thin models, anterior cingulate cortex response to eating disorder behavior words, eating disorder symptoms (d = 0.54), and body dissatisfaction (d = 0.57), and marginally greater reductions in psychosocial impairment (d = 0.39) at posttest, as well as significantly greater reductions in body dissatisfaction (d = 0.68) and psychosocial impairment (d = 0.63), and marginally greater reductions in eating disorder symptoms (d = 0.53) at 6-month follow-up. At posttest, BPT versus IPT participants showed significantly greater abstinence from binge eating and purging (48% versus 23%, respectively) but did not differ on remittance from eating disorder diagnoses (52% versus 44%, respectively).
Conclusions
Results provide further evidence of target engagement for BPT and suggest that it is more effective than IPT in treating a range of eating disorders.
Suicide represents a significant public health concern. Suicide prevention strategies are shifting toward transdiagnostic perspectives examining interrelated risk factors, but their interrelationships remain unclear. This study investigated relationships between psychopathological dimensions, impulsivity, and childhood maltreatment in individuals with suicidal ideation (SI), comparing those with versus without intention to act using network analysis.
Methods
Data were obtained from the Suicide Prevention and Intervention Study project. Participants were categorized into two groups based on their intention to act according to the Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale. Psychological symptoms, impulsivity traits, and childhood maltreatment were assessed. Network analysis was performed, and centrality measures were computed.
Results
A total of 1,265 individuals were categorized into the SI without intention to act (n = 345) and SI with intention to act (n = 920) groups. The former showed lower depression and hostility scores, and lower prevalence of major depressive and anxiety disorders. Network analyses revealed that in the SI without intention to act group, obsessive-compulsive symptoms were central, connecting to depression and anxiety, while negatively correlating with non-planning impulsivity. In contrast, the SI with intention to act group showed a more densely interconnected network where emotional abuse served as a bridge between childhood maltreatment and other psychopathological dimensions.
Conclusions
This study identifies symptom interaction patterns between individuals with SI without and with intention to act. Understanding these relationships may improve suicide risk assessment and inform personalized interventions, potentially reducing the transition from ideation to action. Trauma-focused approaches addressing emotional abuse may be especially relevant for individuals at high risk.
Persistent physical symptoms (PPS) are associated with functional impairment, psychological distress and high healthcare costs. They often span multiple diagnostic categories, resulting in substantial challenges for patients and healthcare systems. Understanding the shared processes underlying PPS is crucial to improving outcomes. PPS are shaped by complex and interacting psychological and physiological mechanisms, which interact to perpetuate the condition. A transdiagnostic approach, which targets shared underlying processes, may offer a more efficient and effective framework for treatment compared with traditional disorder-specific interventions. This article describes the theory for a transdiagnostic approach and evidence for its effectiveness. We describe several theoretical models and approaches to understanding the underlying mechanisms of PPS, including central sensitisation, avoidance behaviours, emotion dysregulation and cognitive distortions. We describe interventions, particularly those incorporating key principles of cognitive–behavioural therapy. The proposed approach integrates these insights to inform a comprehensive treatment model.
Mentalization-based treatment (MBT) has promising transdiagnostic applications. The evidence base for its application in non-specialist settings, including general adult community mental health services requires further evaluation. This study explores the implementation of an MBT introductory (MBTi) group in an Irish secondary mental health service.
Methods:
Two online MBTi groups were delivered between 2020 and 2021. A concurrent mixed-methods design was engaged. Qualitative pre- and post-intervention measures include the Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation (CORE) scale, the World Health Organization Quality-of-Life (WHOQoL-BREF) scale and the Reflective Functioning Questionnaire (RFQ). Paired sample t-test was employed to analyse change. Interviews were conducted with seven participants post-intervention and inductive thematic analysis was utilised to identify themes.
Results:
Participants exhibited hypomentalizing tendencies, which improved following the delivery of the intervention (RFQu: MD = 0.54, p = 0.032, Cohen’s d = 0.71). There were improvements across the wellbeing, problems and functioning subscales of the CORE. There was no change in the risk domain, which was low at baseline. Improvements were observed in the WHOQoL-BREF subscale of psychological health and social relationships. Five main themes emerged from post-intervention interviews: barriers and facilitators; attitudes to design and delivery; perceived intervention effectiveness; intervention coherence; COVID-19 specific issues.
Conclusions:
MBTi delivered in a non-specialist setting is associated with improvements in mentalizing capacity. The intervention is perceived as relevant and useful by participants, although the psychoeducation and online format conferred specific limitations. The findings support the role of MBTi as a feasible transdiagnostic intervention in general adult services, as part of a range of interventions.
Co-morbid mental health diagnoses present challenges for services structured to provide disorder-specific models of treatment, such as NHS Talking Therapies services. Intolerance of uncertainty (IU) has been identified as both disorder specific and transdiagnostic, although little research explores transdiagnostic approaches to treatment of IU alone. A transdiagnostic cognitive behavioural therapy treatment targeting IU, the ‘Making Friends with Uncertainty’ (MFWU) group, was developed and piloted in a Talking Therapies primary care service in an earlier evaluation (Mofrad et al., 2020). The aim of this study was to replicate and further evaluate the intervention. Twenty people presenting with a range of anxiety disorders started the intervention in two groups. The study used a single group, within-subjects quasi-experimental design, collecting data at eight points for routine outcome measures of anxiety, depression and functioning, and five points for measures of anxiety disorder-specific symptoms and IU. Intention-to-treat analyses showed improvement on a general measure of anxiety as well as improvement on the measure of IU. Significantly there was improvement on the disorder specific measures even though the intervention was aimed at the underlying process of IU, rather than the particular symptoms targeted by these measures. The MFWU group may be an efficient and effective way to deliver a highly specified transdiagnostic intervention for intolerance of uncertainty when people are treated in a mixed group format.
Key learning aims
(1) To consider the effectiveness of a transdiagnostic group targeting IU.
(2) To develop understanding of a group intervention for building tolerance to uncertainty.
(3) To consider the impact of targeting IU on specific anxiety disorders.
(4) To offer a methodological framework for effectively evaluating a group intervention in routine practice.
The management of persistent physical symptoms poses a challenge in many healthcare settings, including primary care. Psychological treatments that involve exposure have shown promise for several conditions where patients suffer from persistent physical symptoms and unwanted responses to these. It is unclear, however, to what extent exposure therapy has effects beyond existing routine care interventions and who benefits the most.
Methods
A randomized controlled trial at a primary care center in Stockholm, Sweden compared 10 weeks of internet-delivered exposure therapy (n = 80) to healthy lifestyle promotion (HLP; n = 81) for patients bothered by at least one persistent physical symptom. The primary outcome was the mean reduction in subjective somatic symptom burden (Patient Health Questionnaire 15) as measured week-by-week up to the post-treatment assessment. Secondary outcomes included symptom preoccupation, anxiety, depression symptoms, and functional impairment.
Results
Patients contributed 1544 datapoints during treatment. The primary analysis showed no significant advantage of exposure therapy versus HLP in the reduction of mean somatic symptom burden (d = 0.14; p = 0.220). In secondary analyses, exposure showed superiority in the reduction of symptom preoccupation (d = 0.31; p = 0.033) but not anxiety, depression symptoms, or functional impairment. A higher somatic symptom burden or symptom preoccupation before treatment was predictive of a larger advantage of exposure versus HLP.
Conclusions
Exposure therapy does not appear to show noteworthy average benefit over HLP, with the exception of symptom preoccupation. Substantial benefits are seen in patients with very high symptom burden or symptom preoccupation.
Comprehend, Cope and Connect (CCC) is a trauma-informed, transdiagnostic and evidence-based psychological intervention for mental health crises that can be applied cross-culturally. CCC has been implemented in acute and crisis mental health settings across the South of England and in services elsewhere in the UK. More recently, it has been taken up and adapted for specialist community settings, including perinatal services, addiction services and primary care settings. A continuously growing evidence base indicates that CCC could be the next step towards solving the national problem of mental health crises. It is now time for CCC to be piloted and researched nationally.
A significant number of people diagnosed with BPD experience emptiness. Service-users report that feelings of emptiness are intolerable, terrifying, and debilitating, and research shows that it is contributory to self-harming and suicidal behaviors including completion of suicide. Yet this criterion seems to be the least investigated of any of the nine criteria. This chapter examines what ‘emptiness’ is and whether current research reflects necessary and sufficient conditions for the concept. I describe prevailing thinking on the development of BPD and emptiness. The chapter then turns to experiences of emptiness that are found in other diagnoses, everyday life, and cross-culturally. I suggest that not all experiences of emptiness are signs of pathology. The second half of the chapter focuses on treatment possibilities, focusing on people diagnosed with BPD. I set out the main ideas in Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT) and then work with one of the core methods in DBT for skill-building—mindfulness—to argue that some service-users may benefit from practicing Buddhist meditation. I conclude by discussing and responding to critics of such a position, after which I emphasize that Buddhist meditation is not for everyone and is only one option for treatment of feelings of emptiness.
This book offers an interdisciplinary perspective on personality disorder with chapters by philosophers, psychiatrists, and psychological scientists. Written to be accessible to all three disciplines, it updates traditional conceptualizations and offers new and novel perspectives on personality disorder, with a special emphasis on borderline and narcissistic personalities. Featuring contributions from established senior researchers as well as early career scholars from across four continents, it offers surveys of contemporary research and clinical expertise that together plumb the foundational understandings of personality disorder.