To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
This chapter lays out the metatheoretic approach of the book. The focus is on how scientists use experimental work to support compositional hypotheses. It sets aside questions of how scientists might reason in the lab or how scientists might support hypotheses in review articles or textbooks. It brackets questions of the warrant of scientific reasoning. It addresses some of the challenges facing the use of case studies.
This chapter contrasts the theory of singular compositional abduction with Gilbert Harman’s picture of inference to the best explanation. Most notably, Harman’s work is meant to argue that warranted enumerative induction is a special case of inference to the best explanation. It is not, in the first instance, a theory of the scientific interpretation of experimental results. A key element in Harman’s inference to the best explanation is that it is a matter of warranted abductive inference. In trying to understand the scientific interpretation of a single experimental result, one should not assume a priori that an abductive interpretation is warranted. Instead, one should allow that the warrant for some hypothesis only emerges, if it ever does, over the course of a prolonged period of scientific investigation.
Uniform momentum zones (UMZs) are widely used to describe and model the coherent structure of wall-bounded turbulent flows, but their detection has traditionally relied on relatively narrow fields of view which preclude fully resolving features at the scale of large-scale motions (LSMs). We refine and extend recent proposals to detect UMZs with moving-window fields of view by including physically motivated coherency criteria. Using synthetic data, we show how this updated moving-window approach can eliminate noise contamination that is likely responsible for the previously reported, high fractal dimension of UMZ interfaces. By applying the approach to channel flow direct numerical simulation (DNS), we identify a significant number of previously undetected, large-scale UMZ interfaces, including a small fraction of highly linear interfaces with well-defined streamwise inclination angles. We show that the inclination angles vary inversely with the size of the UMZ interfaces and that this relationship can be modelled by the opposing effects of shear-induced inclination and vortex-induced lift-up on hairpin packets. These geometric properties of large-scale UMZ interfaces play an important role in the development of improved stochastic models of wall-bounded turbulence.
Some Hippocratic doctors regarded sleep as a healthy process, and some as a pathological one; some of them struggled to distinguish between hallucinations and nightmares, and some between deep dreamless sleep and total loss of consciousness. This chapter explores how different treatises from the Hippocratic corpus navigated these ambiguities, how they explained different depth of sleep (i.e. different levels of consciousness), and how such understanding relates to their views on mental capacities (which they subsumed in concepts such as phronesis, sunesis, gnômê, and nous).
We extend a classical model of continuous opinion formation to explicitly include an age-structured population. We begin by considering a stochastic differential equation model which incorporates ageing dynamics and birth/death processes, in a bounded confidence type opinion formation model. We then derive and analyse the corresponding mean field partial differential equation and compare the complex dynamics on the microscopic and macroscopic levels using numerical simulations. We rigorously prove the existence of stationary states in the mean field model, but also demonstrate that these stationary states are not necessarily unique. Finally, we establish connections between this and other existing models in various scenarios.
A diachronic look at the contrast between mental illness and impaired consciousness among these ancient doctors shows a trend towards a more compartmentalised idea of these conditions, a stronger notion of disease, and a progressive abstract framing of clinical findings into theoretical classificatory models and comprehensive pathophysiological systems.
In multiparty systems, parties signal conflict through communication, yet standard approaches to measuring partisan conflict in communication consider only the verbal dimension. We expand the study of partisan conflict to the nonverbal dimension by developing a measure of conflict signaling based on variation in a speaker’s expressed emotional arousal, as indicated by changes in vocal pitch. We demonstrate our approach using comprehensive audio data from parliamentary debates in Denmark spanning more than two decades. We find that arousal reflects prevailing patterns of partisan polarization and predicts subsequent legislative behavior. Moreover, we show that consistent with a strategic model of behavior, arousal tracks the electoral and policy incentives faced by legislators. All results persist when we account for the verbal content of speech. By documenting a novel dimension of elite communication of partisan conflict and providing evidence for the strategic use of nonverbal signals, our findings deepen our understanding of the nature of elite partisan communication.
Suicide remains one of the leading causes of death globally, with growing evidence that humanitarian emergencies and fragile states, most of which unfold in low- to middle-income countries (LMICs), are associated with elevated risk of suicide. However, the few suicide-targeted interventions for use in humanitarian contexts remain both sparse and fragmented. This scoping review aims to identify and synthesise evidence from suicide and self-harm prevention interventions implemented in all types of humanitarian settings, globally, that have been evaluated for their effectiveness in improving suicide and self-harm-related outcomes. We systematically searched eight electronic databases, including two grey literature databases, and relevant organisational websites for records published through November 2024 and in any language. Screening was done using the Covidence platform, with each record independently screened by two reviewers. Among other preselected inclusion criteria, studies must have conducted a quantitative evaluation of the effectiveness of an intervention on improving suicide and self-harm-related outcomes during a humanitarian crisis to be included for data extraction. Data extraction and quality assessment were both conducted by two authors. In all, 6,209 records were screened at the title and abstract phase; 104 were included for full text screening; and 23 studies were included for data extraction. Most studies were conducted during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic (COVID-19), and in high-income countries. Evaluated interventions encompassed various approaches, including psychotherapeutic, practical, and pharmacological assistance, often employing multiple components. The majority targeted the general population, were delivered via remote modalities and relied on mental health specialists for their administration. Overall, 15 (65.2%) interventions were associated with statistically significant positive effects on suicide and or self-harm-related outcomes. Promising approaches include cognitive behavioural therapy-based text services, skills-building programmes, and strategies that foster supportive environments for high-risk individuals. These findings highlight both promising approaches and critical gaps in suicide prevention efforts in humanitarian settings. The limited evidence base – particularly in LMICs and with particularly at-risk populations – alongside the increasing frequency of humanitarian crises, underscores the urgent need for future implementation and associated research of suicide and self-harm prevention initiatives within humanitarian contexts.
Divergent perspectives are typically rooted in contrasting worldviews which, in their own right, help to establish a certain social order and structure social relations in determined ways. Worldviews not only grant meaning to individual existence; they also help communities to pursue collective goals that advance their members’ mutual interests. In their turn, individuals establish communities and participate in collective actions in pursuit of their own interests. This chapter argues that human action is, in this manner, characteristically self-interested and oriented towards social relations at the service of collective projects. These collective projects are legitimated by common sense that grants meaning to social objects and events. Processes of social re-presentation serve to fashion objectifications that do not challenge a community’s underlying project. In this way, overcoming conflict requires unpacking contrasting action strategies in terms of projects supported by logical perspectives – that is, perspectives that make sense to the individuals involved. We propose an argumentation analysis protocol that serves to identify convergent claims. Whilst these do not reconcile contrasting projects, they provide the building blocks for mutually satisfactory solutions and reveal targets for social representation intervention.
Tuberculosis (TB) remains a serious health threat and strains of TB resistant to first-line therapies account for significant TB-related morbidity and mortality. Widely recognized as a disease of poverty concentrated in low- and middle-income countries, drug-resistant tuberculosis (DR-TB) is a result of deep-seated deprivation and the shortcomings of under-resourced health systems. Traditionally, the response to TB, and particularly DR-TB, has been focused on dealing with the infection and preventing onward transmission, for example, through isolating people with TB in sanatoria or specialized hospital wards. Recently, activists and policy makers have recognized the need to put people affected by the disease at the center of TB programs, but this is just the beginning of the necessary “just” transition from inequitable and unsustainable approaches to addressing TB to ones that are inclusive, community-centered, and resilient. In this article, we examine antimicrobial resistance in TB and highlight the need for a multisectoral, justice-oriented approach that goes beyond biomedical paradigms—we propose a “just” transition that addresses the unequal burden of human suffering and injustices that have become systemic in TB programs. We see a “just transition” as involving long-term structural changes to technologies, policy, infrastructure, scientific knowledge, and practice.
This chapter adds three principal observations to the theory of singular compositional explanation. These observations are essential to locating the theory of singular compositional explanation to the context of scientific experimental work. The first observation is that scientists sometimes explain the rates of activity instances. One way they explain them is in terms of the number of lower level individuals engaged in activity instances. The second is that scientists often use singular compositional abductive explanations in explaining experimental results. Third, scientists often use singular compositional abductive explanations in the context of controlled experiments.
Evaluate and improve the accuracy of disaster triage decisions for pediatric patients among clinicians of various training levels using the Sort, Assess, Life-Saving Intervention, Treatment/Transport (SALT) triage system.
Methods
We used an online pediatric disaster triage module to evaluate and improve accuracy of triage decisions. During a pre- and post-test activity, participants triaged 20 fictional patients. Between activities, participants completed a didactic covering concepts of disaster triage, SALT triage, and pediatric limitations of triage systems. We assessed accuracy and improvement with non-parametric tests.
Results
There were 48 participants: 27 pediatric emergency medicine attendings (56%), 9 pediatric emergency medicine fellows (19%), 12 pediatric residents (25%). The median (interquartile range [IQR]) pre-test percent accuracy across all participants was 75 (IQR 65-85). Attendings scored higher than residents 80 (IQR 73-88) compared to 60 (IQR 55-65, P < 0.01) but not significantly higher than fellows 75 (IQR 70-85, P = 0.6). For the 44 participants who completed both the pre- and post-test, median score significantly improved from 75 (65-85) to 80 (75-90), P < 0.01.
Conclusions
The accuracy of triage decisions varies at different training levels. An online module can deliver just-in-time triage training and improve accuracy of triage decisions for pediatric patients, especially among pediatric residents.