Skip to main content Accessibility help
Internet Explorer 11 is being discontinued by Microsoft in August 2021. If you have difficulties viewing the site on Internet Explorer 11 we recommend using a different browser such as Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome, Apple Safari or Mozilla Firefox.

Chapter 3: Competence assessment: A clinical approach

Chapter 3: Competence assessment: A clinical approach

pp. 43-76

Authors

, University of Melbourne, , Dean of the Melbourne Graduate School of Education, University of Melbourne, since 2004., , Coordinator of Assessment, Learning and Teaching (Secondary) at the University of Melbourne and a teaching specialist at the Assessment Research Centre.
Resources available Unlock the full potential of this textbook with additional resources. There are free resources available for this textbook. Explore resources
  • Add bookmark
  • Cite
  • Share

Summary

Learning Objectives

In this chapter you will learn to:

  • • understand the developmental model of learning

  • • understand developmental frameworks, including taxonomies, hypothetical

  • progressions, curriculum progressions and derived progressions

  • • identify the zone of actual development (ZAD) and the zone of proximal development (ZPD) using examples of student work against the Assessment Research Centre's Progression of Reading Comprehension, Progression of Numeracy or Progression of Problem Solving

  • This chapter promotes the understanding of developmental learning, introducing hierarchies and taxonomies developed by Bloom and Krathwohl. Because almost everyone working in this mode will be beginners, we will concentrate on the most basic, those relating to cognitive and affective domains. Other taxonomies, including those by Biggs and Collis (SOLO) and by Dreyfus (Skills), are useful and important; the reader can expand their knowledge of these as they become more proficient in assessment. The chapter makes a distinction between the deficit and developmental approaches to teaching and addresses the implications of data use in these two models. The chapter shows teachers how to identify the ‘zone of proximal development’ (ZPD) following Vygotsky, and uses examples of student work to illustrate this concept. The implications of correct identification and the importance of differentiated instruction are also introduced in this chapter. The establishment of a strong link between teaching and assessment data provides the reader with a framework within which to operate as a teacher.

    Introduction

    Students accumulate skills and knowledge through a process of maturation and through engagement in learning activities. But the skills and knowledge accumulated by each student in the class or the year level almost certainly will not be the same. A teacher's role is to identify how best to facilitate this growth in each student. It is common to hear the description of the teacher's role linked to diagnosis in the context of teaching being a clinical practice profession. Although the word diagnosis has typically and traditionally been used to indicate that something is wrong and needs to be fixed, increasingly it is being used to identify individual needs in the educational context. The latter is exactly what teachers need to do, but it is important that we do not confuse student needs with student weaknesses or inadequacies. Students do not go to school to be fixed; they are not sick or in need of prescribed remedies; they go to school to grow socially and cognitively and perhaps morally.

    About the book

    Access options

    Review the options below to login to check your access.

    Purchase options

    eTextbook
    US$74.00
    Paperback
    US$74.00

    Have an access code?

    To redeem an access code, please log in with your personal login.

    If you believe you should have access to this content, please contact your institutional librarian or consult our FAQ page for further information about accessing our content.

    Also available to purchase from these educational ebook suppliers